Revisionism in Castle Studies: A Caution

Colin Platt

Medieval Archaeology · 2007 · 36 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Castle studies have been hijacked by followers of the historian Charles Coulson, whose uncompromising stance, little changed since the 1970s when he began his research on licences to crenellate, has always been that castles were only exceptionally built for military reasons and were 'chiefly an expression of status'. Coulson's ideas have gained particular prominence since 1991, following the publication of his well-received paper on Bodiam Castle. Accepted almost universally by the new generation of castellologists, Coulson's conclusions look set to become the new orthodoxy. This paper challenges those conclusions, concentrating on the late-medieval private fortress (where the Coulson thesis is most persuasive) and beginning with the so-called 'Battle for Bodiam'. It argues that while castles of all dates had many other functions including self-promotion, it was defence that remained the first consideration of almost every castle-builder throughout the Middle Ages; also, that it was increasing social mobility, defined as class structural change, that chiefly conditioned the apparent domestication of the castle in its last years. It was neither status nor nostalgia that caused new castles to be built in late-medieval England, but the ruling circumstances of class mobility and public order.

References

5