A Comparison of the Use of Cleithra to the Use of Scales for Age and Growth Studies

Edward J. Harrison, Wayne F. Hadley

Transactions of the American Fisheries Society · 1979 · 22 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Cleithra and scales were obtained from each of 110 muskellunge captured by anglers in the Niagara River. The results obtained from cleithral age-and-growth analysis were compared to those from a similar scale analysis. Ages agreed on 87% of the sample. When ages disagreed, it was most often judged that the cleithral age was correct. Fish older than IX+ years could not be aged from scales, but cleithra were useful for fish as old as XVI+ years. Lengths back-calculated from the two techniques were statistically (95% level) equivalent at all ages except age I.