Councillors' Notions of Democracy, and their Role Perception and Behaviour in the Changing Context of Local Democracy

Hubert Heinelt

Local Government Studies · 2012 · 60 citations · 7 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract This article starts with an analysis of responses by councillors which can be related either to a representative or to a broader participatory understanding of democracy. This general pattern appears, with slight variations, in all the countries included in the study on councillors in municipal assemblies. The findings on the understanding of democracy will be linked to the formal horizontal power relations between councillors, the mayor and the leading bureaucrats of the municipal administration, as determined by different local government systems. This is done to test whether or not the appearance of councillors with a particular understanding of democracy is determined by different institutional conditions which offer councillors options to perform a specific role according to their understanding of democracy. Also considered is the question of whether councillors' understanding of democracy is linked to personal characteristics. As argued in the introduction to this special issue, particular options offered to councillors by a council's formal competences may neither attract nor repel actors with a specific understanding of democracy to become councillors. Instead, notions of democracy as expressions of a person's basic beliefs and subjective norms can be related to that individual's personal character. Finally, councillors' role perceptions, role behaviour and attitudes towards reforms at the local level are identified and analysed to see whether or not councillors' notions of democracy can be related to their role perceptions, role behaviour and attitudes towards reforms as dependent variables. Key Words: Local democracynotion of democracyrole perception of municipal councillorsrole behaviour of municipal councillorsreforms at the local level Notes 1. I am grateful for the support and comments of Björn Egner and Max-Christopher Krapp as well as of the authors of the other contributions and the two anonymous reviewers of this special issue. 2. See for instance Habermas Citation1992, pp. 349–353, Habermas Citation1996b, Pierre and Peters Citation2000, pp.137–141, or Cohen Citation2007 and for early debates Pateman Citation1970 and Pitkin Citation1967 (the latter especially for the mandate-independence controversy). 3. The question was: 'People have different ideas about how local democracy should function. Please indicate how important for local democracy you feel the following requirements are?' 4. The first two statements were also possible answers to the question: 'People have different ideas about how local democracy should function. Please indicate how important for local democracy you feel the following requirements are?' The two last statements were possible answers to the question: 'How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements?' 5. Factor loads lower than 0.5 are not displayed here nor in the rest of this article. 6. One could argue that the notions about representative and participatory democracy are not independent from each other which is the basic assumption for using factor analysis with rotated, orthogonal factors which show a correlation of r = 0 by definition. I also tried to skip the assumption by using oblique rotation, but the result is very similar to the one of the original (orthogonal) rotation, and the factors of the oblique rotation only correlate with r = 0.1; i.e. even without the assumption of non-correlating factors, the latent variables are virtually independent from each other. 7. For other typologies of local government systems and their conceptual weaknesses and strengths see the overview in Heinelt and Hlepas 2006. 8. Levene's test for equality of variances results in F = 3.724 with p = .054. 9. A number of other variables were also tested. However, neither the number of years in office nor the size of the municipality in which the councillors serve play a significant role with respect to the councillors' notion of democracy. The same applies to whether or not the councillor had been elected as a candidate on the list of a national party, on a local list, as an individual, or as an independent candidate. Finally, being currently a member of a party (or not) does not feature. 10. Councillors were asked to respond to the following question: 'There is often talk about a left-right dimension in politics. Where would you place yourself on a left-right dimension?' 11. The classification of parties was based on the MANIFESTO categories. See Klingemann et al.Citation2006 and http://www.wzb.eu/zkd/dsl/pdf/Manifesto-Project.pdf.

References

7