Multilateral Trade and Militarized Conflict: Centrality, Openness, and Asymmetry in the Global Trade Network

Brandon J Kinne

The Journal of Politics · 2012 · 151 citations · 61 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Studies of the trade‑conflict relationship typically emphasize dyadic over multilateral trade, ignoring large‑scale effects of trade integration, and the common openness measure is conceptually problematic and yields inconsistent empirical results. The study develops a network‑based framework for trade integration and applies it to multilateral trade–conflict theory. The authors operationalize integration through measures of breadth, depth, and commercial distance of trade ties and extend dyadic trade–conflict models to the multilateral level. Extensive country‑year analysis shows that network centrality unilaterally constrains aggression, with more central states initiating fewer conflicts even when trade ties are highly asymmetric.

Abstract

Studies of the trade-conflict relationship typically emphasize dyadic over multilateral trade, ignoring the large-scale effects of trade integration. Openness, a common measure of integration, is conceptually problematic and yields inconsistent empirical results. Drawing on the concept of network centrality, I develop a network approach to integration, emphasizing three aspects of multilateral trade: breadth of trade ties, depth of trade ties, and commercial distance between nonpartners. I then extend the dyadic logics of the trade-conflict literature to the multilateral level, focusing on (1) theories that predict that trade reduces conflict, either by increasing opportunity costs or by creating signaling mechanisms, and (2) theories that predict that trade, especially when asymmetric, increases the political autonomy of states and thus encourages aggression. Extensive country-year analysis shows that, consistent with the first set of theories, network centrality unilaterally constrains aggression. More central states initiate fewer conflicts, even when their trade ties are highly asymmetric.

References

61