The interchange of disease and health between the Old and New Worlds.

Giovanni Berlinguer

American Journal of Public Health · 1992 · 31 citations · 2 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The five centuries since Columbus’s discovery reveal how the Old and New Worlds have mutually shaped disease history and treatment, while also highlighting emerging health, cultural, and environmental consequences of this exchange. The study evaluates how the exchange between the Old and New Worlds has affected population decline, disease spread, nutrition, drug addiction, health service models, and bioethical issues, arguing that the discovery shifted the world from isolation to global interdependence. The authors analyze historical causes of population decline, disease diffusion, nutritional impacts, drug addiction trends, diagnostic and treatment practices, and health service models across the Atlantic. The paper concludes that the post‑Columbian shift from isolation to global interdependence has raised bioethical challenges and potential epidemic risks, and that learning from history can foster future cooperation and solidarity.

Abstract

A review of the five centuries since Columbus discovered America helps us understand the mutual contributions of the Old and the New Worlds to the history of diseases and their treatment. It also shows the consequences of this "mutual discovery" as they are currently emerging in the fields of health, culture, and the environment. To evaluate the multiple aspects of the interchange between the Old and New Worlds, this paper discusses the following: the causes of the rapid decline of the original American populations; the diffusion of communicable diseases between the two civilizations; the health consequences of nutritional changes on both sides of the Atlantic; drug addictions, as they developed through the centuries and as they exist today; the ways diseases were and are evaluated, prevented, diagnosed, and treated; and the mutual impact of different models of health services. Arguing that a major global change following the discovery of America was the transition from isolation of the two worlds to communication, and, more recently, to global interdependence, the paper also discusses some problems of bioethical relevance and the possible impact of new epidemics. Finally, it suggests that a critical analysis of the past may help stimulate future cooperation and solidarity.

References

2