Political Studies · 2009 · 317 citations · 33 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyPublic PolicyEpistemologyPhilosophy Of SciencePolicy AnalysisEvidence-based PolicymakingPolicy FormulationPolicy LearningPolicy MakingPolicy PracticeSocial EpistemologyAdaptive SystemsEvidence Informed PolicyEvidence-based Decision MakingEvidence-informed Decision-makingInstrumental RationalityNormative JudgmentsNormative LearningPolicy Making Process
The credentials of the evidence-based policy movement appear to be increasingly subject to challenge based on research that has highlighted the limits on the use of evidence in policy making. However, moves towards a more ‘realistic’ position of evidence-informed policy making risk conflating prescription with description and undermining a normative vision of better policy making. This article argues that we need to review the ideas that underpin our thinking about evidence-based policy making, and move beyond the territory of instrumental rationality to a position founded upon two intellectual pillars: our developing knowledge about complex adaptive systems; and ideas from a pragmatist philosophical position – especially those of John Dewey – about social scientific knowledge and its role in guiding action to address social problems. This leads us to a conception of ‘intelligent policy making’ in which the notion of policy learning is central.
33
Choice Reviews Online · 1990 · 19.5K citations
Choice Reviews Online · 2000 · 1.9K citations
T. V. Smith, John Dewey · The Philosophical Review · 1929 · 1.9K citations
Evidence, argument, and persuasion in the policy process
Choice Reviews Online · 1990 · 1.3K citations