American Journal of Roentgenology · 1999 · 70 citations · 26 references
MedicineRadiologyDiagnostic ImagingDiagnostic RadiologyInterventional RadiologyAbdominal ImagingAbdominal RadiologyHepatobiliary ImagingHepatobiliary SurgeryImage-guided BiopsyLiver BiopsyHepatobiliary Point-of-care UltrasonographyImage-guided Liver AspirationLiver Lesion DetectionLiver UltrasoundNeedle Biopsy TechniquePercutaneous Liver BiopsyPercutaneous Tumor BiopsyUltrasound-guided Liver Biopsy
OBJECTIVE: We compared the relative cost of a liver biopsy performed with sonographic guidance with that of one performed with CT guidance in a cost-benefit analysis model. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Variables were estimated from a search of the literature and from clinical experience with 437 hepatic biopsies at our institution. Probability variables included the probability of obtaining an adequate sample and the probability of a major complication. Cost variables included the direct and indirect costs, the cost of a major complication, and the opportunity costs of foregone revenue from preempted diagnostic studies. One-way and two-way sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Using baseline values, CT guidance was 1.89 times more expensive than sonographic guidance. Sensitivity analyses indicate that CT and sonographic guidance costs would be equivalent if the success rate with sonographic guidance was 39.8%, the opportunity costs of CT guidance were 3.13 times less than best estimates, and the opportunity costs of sonography were 3.15 times greater than best estimates. CONCLUSION: Sonographic guidance for hepatic biopsies is substantially more economical than CT guidance across a wide range of estimated costs.
26
CT-guided biopsy: prospective analysis of 1,000 procedures.
Tasha L. Welch, Patrick F. Sheedy, C. Daniel Johnson et al. · Radiology · 1989 · 237 citations
CT- and US-guided biopsy of the pancreas.
Kathleen R. Brandt, J. William Charboneau, D H Stephens et al. · Radiology · 1993 · 233 citations
Risk in fine‐needle abdominal biopsy
Tito Livraghi, B Damascelli, Claudio Lombardi et al. · Journal of Clinical Ultrasound · 1983 · 228 citations
Abdominal percutaneous interventional procedures: comparison of CT and US guidance.
Douglas H. Sheafor, E K Paulson, C.Michael Simmons et al. · Radiology · 1998 · 123 citations