Religion: A Confounding Cultural Element in the International Harmonization of Accounting?

Shaari A. Hamid, Russell Craig, Frank Clarke

Abacus · 1993 · 200 citations · 6 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Culture, especially religion, has been largely overlooked in international accounting harmonization, with prior focus on indigenous characteristics confined within national boundaries; Islam exemplifies how transnational religious norms can shape accounting practices. The study examines how Islam may influence accounting structure, concepts, and mechanisms in the Islamic world. Islamic principles enforce a specific ethical code governing commercial and personal behavior, thereby affecting business structuring and financing among Muslims and between Muslims and non‑Muslims. The analysis demonstrates that religion, as illustrated by Islam, acts as a confounding factor in assessing national accounting idiosyncrasies and hampers international harmonization.

Abstract

Discussion of the influence of culture on the international development and harmonization of accounting has focused primarily upon indigenous characteristics which are confined within national boundaries. But cultural inputs, such as religion, which transcend national boundaries, should not be overlooked. Islam is a particular case in point. Its principles commit Muslims to a definitive code of ethical commercial and personal behaviour affecting both the structuring and financing of business affairs between the faithful, and between Muslims and non‐Muslims. Islam has the potential for influencing the structure, underlying concepts and the mechanisms of accounting in the Islamic world. Its potential for influencing accounting policy is illustrative of religion as a confounding element in the analysis of national idiosyncrasies in accounting practice and in deconstructing the impediments to international harmonization.

References

6