Was Prometheus Unbound by Chance? Risk, Diversification, and Growth

Daron Acemoğlu, Fabrizio Zilibotti

Journal of Political Economy · 1997 · 1.5K citations · 27 references

TL;DR

Early development stages limit risk spreading, constraining the economy’s ability to diversify. The paper proposes a theory linking market incompleteness to capital accumulation and growth. The theory shows that risk avoidance slows capital accumulation, limited diversification amplifies growth uncertainty, producing a prolonged primitive accumulation phase followed by takeoff and steady growth, and it extends to economies with international capital flows. The model predicts that luckier countries exit the primitive accumulation phase sooner and grow faster, yet even in a price‑taking, spillover‑free setting the decentralized equilibrium remains inefficient because agents ignore how their risk‑avoidance affects others’ diversification opportunities.

Abstract

This paper offers a theory of development that links the degree of market incompleteness to capital accumulation and growth. At early stages of development, the presence projects limits the degree of risk spreading (diversification) that the economy can achieve. The desire to avoid highly risky investments slows down capital accumulation, and the inability to diversify idiosyncratic risk introduces a large amount of uncertainty in the growth process. The typical development pattern will consist of a lengthy period of "primitive accumulation" with highly variable output, followed by takeoff and financial deepening and, finally, steady growth. "Lucky" countries will spend relatively less time in the primitive accumulation stage and develop faster. Although all agents are price takers and there are no technological spillovers, the decentralized equilibrium is inefficient because individuals do not take into account their impact on others' diversification opportunities. We also show that our results generalize to economies with international capital flows.

References

27