Philosophy Compass · 2006 · 41 citations · 19 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyAestheticsContemporary ArtMoral PsychologyAesthetic ValueArtistic ValuePhilosophy Of ArtVisual ArtsAesthetic EthicsArt ValueArtistic JudgmentRole Of Art
Abstract The (im)moral character of art works often affects how we respond to them. But should it affect our evaluation of them as art? The article surveys the contemporary debate whilst outlining further lines of argument and enquiry. The main arguments in favour of aestheticism, the claim that there is no internal relation between artistic value and moral character, are considered. Nonetheless the connection between art's instructional aspirations and artistic value, as well as the ways in which works solicit responses from us, underwrite the claim that a work's moral character can be directly relevant to a work's value as art. Various competing accounts of how the relationship goes, ethicism, moderate moralism and immoralism, are considered. The article goes on to elaborate novel considerations in favour of a suitably qualified cognitive immoralism and suggests avenues of further enquiry with respect to the moral character of art works.
19
Aesthetics; Problems in the Philosophy of Criticism
Edward A. Lippman, Monroe C. Beardsley · Notes · 1959 · 546 citations
The Expression of Feeling in Imagination
Richard Morán · The Philosophical Review · 1994 · 352 citations · Full text
Aesthetics. Problems in the Philosophy of Criticism.
Frank Sibley, Monroe C. Beardsley · The Philosophical Review · 1961 · 259 citations
Art and Ethical Criticism: An Overview of Recent Directions of Research
Noël Carroll · Ethics · 2000 · 254 citations