Privacy, Confidentiality and Other Legal Considerations in the Establishment of a Centralized Health-Data System

William J. Curran, Barbara Stearns, Honora Kaplan

New England Journal of Medicine · 1969 · 22 citations · 1 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Health‑data systems face significant privacy and confidentiality challenges, as state laws target specific information and federal laws only cover data collected by federal agencies. The paper argues that every health‑data system should implement a code of ethics, clear rules, and statutory criminal and civil penalties for wrongful disclosure. It proposes enforcement through employee dismissal and user bans, statutory penalties, interagency agreements, a privacy committee with public surveillance, and a consortium structure to secure cooperation and public acceptance.

Abstract

Abstract A major issue confronting health-data systems is the protection of privacy and confidentiality. State laws covering health-information disclosure are geared to specific information rather than to comprehensive coverage of all health data. Federal laws cover only data gathered by federal agencies. Every health-data system should adopt a code of ethics and clearly defined rules and regulations governing protection of information. Violation by employees should be grounds for dismissal, and violation by users should bar future access to the system. Criminal as well as civil penalties for wrongful disclosure should be adopted by statute. The system should make use of interagency agreements. A privacy committee and a method of public surveillance should be established. The organizational structure should take the form of a consortium of the contributing agencies to ensure the continuing co-operation and support of these agencies and the greatest public acceptance of the system.

References

1