Journal of European Archaeology · 1995 · 341 citations · 90 references
HumanitiesHistoryEuropean HistoryMasculinity StudiesSelfEuropean CultureHegemonic MasculinityIndividualismMiddle AgesStatus Expression
Ideology has been central to recent interpretations of Europe’s mid‑fifth to second‑millennium BC social transformation, with scholars emphasizing the human body—especially as a prestige‑goods medium—as key to developing a coherent lifestyle, personhood, self‑identity, and a warrior‑specific notion of male beauty. The study aims to critique the prevailing prestige‑goods ideology model for its cynicism and neglect of the socio‑cultural nuances of status expression. The authors link ideological shifts to the emergence of a male warrior status group and its expressive themes—individualism, warfare, bodily ornamentation, horses, wheeled vehicles, hunting, and ritual alcohol—to show that bodily treatment in mortuary rites and daily life transcends ideology.
The concept of ideology has figured centrally in recent accounts of the fundamental social transformation sweeping Europe from the mid-fifth to second millennia BC. In particular, many have focussed on the human body as a principal medium of ideological expression, notably in terms of a growing 'prestige goods ideology'. This paper endeavours to expose the deficiencies of this model, which lie in its overly cynical nature and its disregard for the specific socio-cultural contours of status expression. Specifically, by linking the 'ideological' transformations of this Period to the development of a distinct institution, a male warrior status group, and its package of expressive themes - individualism, warfare, bodily ornamentation, horses and wheeled vehicles, the hunt, the ritual consumption of alcohol - I seek to demonstrate that the changing treatment of the human body in mortuary rites and in everyday life is more than ideological. In particular, it is implicated in the development of a coherent life style, and as such is fundamentally bound up with changing notions of Personhood and self-identity. Running through the fabric of this life style, through its embodiment of the subject in both life and death, is an equally distinctive notion of male beauty, unique to the warrior.
90
The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
Kaspar D. Naegele, Erving Goffman · American Sociological Review · 1956 · 26.2K citations
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison.
David W. Tarbet, Alan Sheridan · Eighteenth-Century Studies · 1978 · 19.3K citations
Outline of a Theory of Practice.
Arthur W. Frank, Pierre Bourdıeu · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 1980 · 14.6K citations
Anthony F. C. Wallace, Harold Garfinkel · American Sociological Review · 1968 · 12.6K citations