Academic Emergency Medicine · 2014 · 15 citations · 26 references
MedicineCardiologyEmergency MedicineClinical CardiologyPrehospital Emergency CareResuscitationAcute Coronary Syndrome CareAcute Coronary Syndrome InterventionAcute Coronary SyndromesElectrocardiogram InterpretationElectrocardiography12-Lead ElectrocardiographyAcute Coronary Syndrome ManagementEms Data SystemsNon-st-elevation Myocardial InfarctionPercutaneous Coronary Intervention Care
Guidelines advise that a prehospital electrocardiogram (ECG) should be obtained in any patients with chest pain, yet up to 20% of patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) do not present with chest pain. The objective was to determine the association of atypical presentations in the prehospital setting on the likelihood of receiving a prehospital ECG and subsequent time to reperfusion therapy. This study used a data set that linked prehospital medical information from a statewide EMS data system with a clinical registry of treatment and outcomes data for patients with STEMI. Among 2,639 STEMI patients from 2008 to 2010, the association between non–chest pain presentations, prehospital ECG use, and reperfusion times among patients undergoing primary percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) were examined. Inverse probability weights were used to account for observed baseline confounders. Overall, 318 of 2,639 patients (12.1%) presented without chest pain. A prehospital ECG was obtained in 2,021 of 2,321 (87.1%) patients with chest pain compared with only 230 of 318 (72.3%) without chest pain (odds ratio [OR] = 2.24, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.69 to 2.98). Among patients without chest pain, those who received a prehospital ECG had significantly shorter first medical contact (FMC) to device times (30.9% < 90 minutes vs. 11.4% > 90 minutes, adjusted OR = 2.81, 95% CI = 1.29 to 6.11, p < 0.01). Over one-quarter of STEMI patients presenting without chest pain did not receive prehospital ECGs and had significantly longer FMC to device times. Future efforts are needed to promote the use of prehospital ECGs to achieve more rapid identification of STEMI patients with atypical presentations in the prehospital setting. Las guías clínicas aconsejan que se debería obtener un electrocardiograma (ECG) extrahospitalario en todos los pacientes con dolor torácico. No obstante, hasta un 20% de los pacientes con infarto de miocardio con elevación del ST (IAMCEST) no se presentan con dolor torácico. El objetivo fue determinar la asociación entre presentaciones atípicas en el escenario extrahospitalario y la probabilidad de que se realizase un ECG extrahospitalario y el tiempo para el tratamiento de reperfusión. Este estudio utilizó un conjunto de datos que unieron la información médica extrahospitalaria de un sistema de datos estatal del sistema de emergencias médicas (SEM) con un registro clínico de datos de tratamiento y resultados de los pacientes con IAMCEST. Entre los 2.639 pacientes con IAMCEST registrados desde 2008 a 2010, se examinó la asociación entre las presentaciones con dolor no torácico, el uso de ECG extrahospitalario y los tiempos de reperfusión entre los pacientes donde se llevó a cabo un angioplatia coronaria primaria (ACP). Se usaron los pesos de probabilidad inversa para contabilizar los factores de confusión basales observados. Del total de 2.639 pacientes, 318 (12,1%) no presentaron dolor torácico. Se obtuvo un ECG extrahospitalario en 2.021 de 2.321 (87,1%) de los pacientes con dolor torácico, en comparación con sólo 230 de 318 (72,3%) en aquéllos sin dolor torácico (OR 2,24, IC95% = 1,69 a 2,98). Entre los pacientes sin dolor torácico, aquéllos que recibieron un ECG extrahospitalario tuvieron de forma significativa tiempos más breves del primer contacto médico (30,9% <90 minutos vs. 11,4% > 90 minutos, OR ajustada 2,81, IC95% = 1,29 a 6,11, p < 0,01). N. A una cuarta parte de los pacientes con IAMCEST sin dolor torácico no se les realizó un ECG extrahospitalario y tuvieron tiempos significativamente más prolongados para el primer contacto médico con el dispositivo. Se necesitan esfuerzos en el futuro para promocionar el uso del ECG extrahospitalario para conseguir una identificación mexgrahospitario. rio on IAMEST con prsentacione atmñ tuvieron significativamente mñkl exgrahospitario tuvieron de forma signitivás rápida de los pacientes con IAMCEST con presentaciones atípicas en el ámbito extrahospitalario. Coronary heart disease, including ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI), is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in the United States.1 Outcomes for STEMI can be improved by early reperfusion therapy, including percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) or fibrinolytic therapy.2 Greater than 60% of patients with STEMI arrive to the hospital by emergency medical services (EMS), and therefore, a critical component of STEMI care involves prompt diagnosis via a 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) at the scene or in the ambulance prior to arrival at the hospital.3 For STEMI patients, the use of a prehospital ECG by EMS has been shown to dramatically shorten time to reperfusion therapy because it allows paramedics to provide advanced notification to receiving emergency departments (EDs) and cardiac catheterization labs and also to potentially bypass non-PCI hospitals.4 The decision of first responders to obtain a prehospital ECG on any given patient is largely protocol-driven. Current North Carolina EMS protocols recommend that paramedics obtain ECGs in all patients >30 years old who have chest pain, or those with suspected acute myocardial infarction (MI).5 However, a practical limitation to this approach is that a significant proportion of patients with STEMI do not present with typical symptoms of chest pain. Studies indicate that up to 20% of patients, especially women and the elderly, may not experience chest pain and instead present with atypical symptoms such as dyspnea, weakness, or nausea.6, 7 In the hospital setting, patients who present without chest pain experience significant delays in door-to-ECG time, resulting in delays in treatment, and higher mortality.1, 8, 9 To the best of our knowledge, the effect of atypical (i.e., non–chest pain) STEMI presentation on the likelihood of receiving a prehospital ECG and its association with time to reperfusion has not been delineated. Using a unique data set that merges prehospital EMS data with hospital treatment and outcomes data across North Carolina, our objectives were to 1) describe the initial EMS presenting chief complaints of patients with STEMI, 2) describe the relationship between patients' initial presenting chief complaints and the decisions of EMS to obtain prehospital ECGs, and 3) evaluate if the decision to obtain a prehospital ECG is associated with first medical contact (FMC)-to-device times among patients undergoing primary PCI. We hypothesized that STEMI patients without chest pain would be less likely to receive prehospital ECGs and would therefore have longer treatment times compared to those with chest pain. This was a retrospective cohort study using linked data from two different clinical data sources. The institutional review boards at both the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill and Duke University approved this study. The first data source was The North Carolina Prehospital Medical Information System (PreMIS). PreMIS is a state-mandated, Internet-based EMS information system used by over 500 North Carolina EMS agencies and 30,000 technicians. It registers an estimated 1.2 million records per year.10 These records represent over 98% of 9-1-1 emergency responses statewide. Every EMS agency in North Carolina submits patient data to PreMIS, including demographics, clinical information, presenting signs and symptoms, and use of prehospital diagnostic modalities and/or treatments, such as the administration of medications and 12-lead ECG application. The second data source was the Acute Coronary Treatment and Intervention Outcomes Network (ACTION) Registry–Get with the Guidelines (GWTG) data set. The ACTION-GWTG database contains detailed clinical information for hospitalized patients who are diagnosed with acute MI, including type and timing of in-hospital treatments and patient outcomes. Patient level data from the PreMIS database were joined to the ACTION-GWTG registry for all patients diagnosed with STEMI in North Carolina using deterministic linkage. Seventy percent of all EMS patients were successfully linked, and patient characteristics and treatment of linked and nonlinked patients were similar. The methodology for this linkage has been described in detail in previous publications.11, 12 This linked dataset provides a comprehensive assessment of both prehospital and in-hospital clinical care among STEMI patients who use EMS in North Carolina. For this analysis we started with the entire cohort of linked STEMI patients in North Carolina who arrived to hospitals by EMS (n = 6,498) from June 2008 to September 2010. We focused our analysis on patients who were transported by EMS and taken directly to PCI centers (n = 3,077) and excluded those patients who were initially transported to non-PCI hospitals and later transferred to PCI hospitals. We excluded transfer patients because their data collection forms were completed at PCI hospitals; thus, we could not reliably know whether ECGs performed prior to hospital arrival were actually performed during EMS transport to the non-PCI hospital or during the interfacility transfer. Of note, however, the baseline characteristics of STEMI patients who were transferred were similar to those who presented directly to PCI centers. The PreMIS database records patient chief complaints in free-text format as entered by the EMS responders. Chief complaints were reviewed manually by the primary study investigator (ARC) and classified as chest pain yes versus no. Chest pain was defined as any symptom of chest discomfort, sensation, pressure, or pain localized to either the left or right chest. If the chief complaint field was empty or unreadable or did not contain a chief complaint, then the EMS dispatch complaint and/or secondary complaint fields were used to classify the chief complaint. If none of these fields were used, then the record was excluded from the analysis. In addition, we excluded the following groups of patients: those with cardiac arrest or respiratory arrest on presentation, those who were listed as unconscious or unresponsive, and those where “STEMI” or “MI” was listed by EMS as the chief complaint. A second author (SWG) reviewed a 5% sample and had perfect agreement in classifying chest pain yes versus no. After excluding all patients who either did not meet EMS transport or did not meet symptom criteria, there were 2,639 patient records for analysis. This sample derivation process is illustrated in Figure 1. To determine if the EMS agency obtained a prehospital ECG for a patient, two fields were used. The PreMIS field specifies ECG as a yes/no variable. However, a handful of EMS agencies in North Carolina could not enter data into this field due to a known software incompatibility between some commercial EMS software vendors and PreMIS. Given that the ACTION-GWTG data set also contains a prehospital ECG yes/no field, it was used to supplement the PreMIS data to determine if a patient received a prehospital ECG. As such, if either PreMIS or ACTION-GWTG indicated prehospital ECG yes, then we classified that patient as having received a prehospital ECG. We abstracted patient data from the linked data sets, including patient demographics (age, sex, and race), comorbidities and prior procedures (including current/recent smoker, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, prior MI, prior heart failure, prior PCI, and prior coronary artery bypass graft), and time to treatment for patients undergoing primary PCI (FMC-to-device time). Frequencies and Pearson chi-square statistics were used to describe demographics and characteristics of patients who presented with chest pain compared to patients without chest pain. Next, we examined the association between patients who presented with or without chest pain and their likelihood of receiving prehospital ECGs. We used the inverse probability-weighted (IPW) estimators method as detailed by Curtis et al.13 Previous work has described baseline differences in the characteristics of STEMI patients who present classically with chest pain versus those who present atypically without chest pain.14 To the extent that one group is different from the other group in ways that could affect the decision to obtain an ECG (they are sicker and older, have differences at presentation such as shock, etc.), any observed difference in treatment times between the two groups could reflect underlying differences between these groups rather than their chief complaints.15 Therefore, we used IPW to balance the chest pain and no chest pain groups with respect to observed baseline confounders. Briefly, we used the logistic regression of having chest pain regressed on the covariates of patient demographics, clinical history, presenting signs/symptoms (i.e., the same covariates listed in Table 1) to estimate the predicted probabilities from the fitted model, and obtained the IPW by inversing these predicted probabilities. This was a multivariable analysis in which all the variables in Table 1 were included, with age as the only continuous variable while all others were categorical. We then employed the IPW to a logistic regression model to investigate how a patient chief complaint of chest pain was associated with the EMS decision to obtain a prehospital ECG on the patient. Generalized estimating equations (GEE) were applied to the model to account for EMS agency clustering effects. Our dependent variable was if a prehospital ECG was obtained, and our independent variable was if a patient had chest pain (yes vs. no). In evaluating this model there were no sparse data, and the Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness-of-fit test did not indicate any lack of fit of the models. We performed additional validation on the IPW model. First, we examined the distribution of propensity scores by the presence or absence of chest pain to ensure a reasonable overlap. Next we checked the covariate balance between the group with chest pain and the group without chest pain after IPW by comparing pre- and post-IPW statistics: Cramer's V for categorical variables and r2 for the continuous age variable. Finally, we determined whether the EMS decision to obtain a prehospital ECG mediated differences in FMC-to-device times among those patients with chest pain versus those without chest pain. Again, we fitted a logistic regression model weighted by the derived IPW and applied GEE to adjust for EMS agency clustering effect. Our dependent variable was whether a patient had an FMC-to-device time under the guideline recommendation of 90 minutes. Our independent variables included whether a patient received a prehospital ECG and also an interaction term between chest pain as a chief complaint and prehospital ECG use. We also performed sensitivity analyses where we excluded patients who were in cardiogenic shock at presentation, with the notion that they may have been less able to vocalize a chief complaint. All analyses were performed using SAS version 9.2. We used a two-tailed significance level of α = 0.05 for all assessments. The final linked data set from PreMIS and ACTION-GWTG, after the exclusion criteria were applied, contained 2,639 patient records. Patient demographics and characteristics are displayed in Table 1 and are generally consistent with similar STEMI cohorts described in the literature.15 Of the 2,639 STEMI patients, 2,321 (88.0%, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 84.0% to 86.7%) presented to EMS with chief complaints of chest pain, while 318 patients (12.1%, 95% CI = 10.8% to 13.3%) did not report chest pain on presentation (Table 1). Patients without chest pain were more likely to be elderly and female or have diabetes. Patients who presented with chest pain were more likely to have undergone previous PCI. The regression coefficients of chest pain versus patient characteristics that were subsequently used in the IPW model are also listed in Table 1. Overall, 2,251 of 2,639 patients (85.3%, 95% CI = 84.0% to 86.7%) received prehospital ECGs. Among patients with chest pain, 2,021 of 2,321 (87.1%, 95% CI = 85.7% to 88.4%) received prehospital ECGs. In comparison, only 230 of 318 (72.3%, 95% CI = 67.4% to 77.2%) patients who presented without chest pain received prehospital ECGs (see Figure 2). The IPW GEE logistic regression results showed that a chief complaint of chest pain was a significant predictor of prehospital ECG use by EMS responders (odds ratio [OR] = 2.24, 95% CI = 1.69 to 2.98). Among all patients, 2,323 of 2,639 (88.0%) underwent primary PCI. The median FMC-to-device time was 91 minutes (interquartile range [IQR] = 74 to 114 minutes), with 42.25% of all patients meeting the national 90-minute guideline.16 Patients without chest pain had longer FMC-to-reperfusion times compared to those with chest pain (median FMC-to-device times 103 minutes vs. 90 minutes, percentage with FMC-to-device time under 90 minutes was 25.5% [95% CI = 20.6% to 30.2%] vs. 44.6% [95% CI = 42.5% to 46.6%]). In the IPW regression analysis, the interaction between a chief complaint of chest pain and prehospital ECG application was significant (p < 0.05). This indicates that the EMS decision to obtain a prehospital ECG mediated differences in treatment times among patients without chest pain. In patients with chest pain, treatment times were similar whether or not they received prehospital ECGs (89.5 minutes vs. 90 minutes). In contrast, among patients without chest pain, those who did not receive prehospital ECGs had significantly longer times to treatment compared to those who received ECGs (median FMC-to-device = 138 minutes vs. 99 minutes; percentage with FMC to device time < 90 minutes = 11% vs. 31%, adjusted OR = 2.81, 98% CI = 1.29 to 6.11). These data for all groups and subgroups are displayed in Figure 2. We performed additional sensitivity analyses where we excluded patients with cardiogenic shock in addition to those with cardiac arrest. There were no changes in results in the main effects models. In a novel, statewide linked database between EMS and registry data we observed that approximately 12% of patients ultimately diagnosed with STEMI presented to EMS without chest pain. These patients without chest pain were significantly less likely to receive prehospital ECGs compared to patients with chest pain. Those patients without chest pain who did not receive prehospital ECGs had significantly longer FMC-to-device times compared to those who did receive a prehospital ECG. To our knowledge, this is the first study on the effect atypical (i.e., non–chest pain) STEMI presentation has on the likelihood of receiving a prehospital ECG and subsequent time to reperfusion. Prehospital ECG use by EMS responders plays a critical role in promptly diagnosing and treating STEMI patients. Nationally, approximately 70% of STEMI patients use EMS for hospital transport.3 A significant percentage of these patients present without chest pain, the elderly, and prehospital North Carolina EMS recommend ECGs in all patients with chest pain, there are no national to those patients without chest pain who should receive prehospital ECGs. In the setting, previous have ECG on a chief complaint and it is not practical or to obtain a prehospital ECG on patient who to a similar approach could also be applied in the prehospital setting. applied to our data a ECG has a sensitivity of study and We observed that patients with chest pain had similar times whether or not they received prehospital ECGs. We that this is because STEMI have without prehospital ECGs, patients with chest pain receive an ECG EMS largely from any such efforts to be by efforts to EMS the symptoms of acute cardiac disease, especially atypical These efforts have been shown to treatment among women and the elderly who have prehospital ECG has been associated with FMC-to-reperfusion times in however, national use and to receiving hospitals have been observed in the years following initial EMS prehospital ECG A of EMS have among their with similar in FMC-to-reperfusion efforts to be to ensure ECG in those that use ECG of EMS responders to and prehospital ECGs is also to data collection and to EMS first responders the of prehospital ECG and treatment times in those patients with atypical STEMI presentations may also first approach to these To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate prehospital chief complaint for STEMI, ECG and subsequent treatment times across a defined Previous work has been largely by the to EMS data with associated treatment and outcomes This study the of a statewide EMS data linkage for evaluating STEMI care and such a registry may in acute in which EMS is such as and cardiac arrest. This was an study using data from a clinical information system and a clinical registry in which approximately 70% of all patients were successfully therefore, we between prehospital ECG use and treatment times. our data only included those patients who were transported to PCI therefore, patients who were first transported to non-PCI centers or those who en were not included in our analysis. We therefore have data on ECG use among more EMS agencies where with and are likely more some EMS agencies may prehospital ECG application protocols to different our IPW model that there are no confounders. there is no to this the IPW approach provide of all effects in these treatment We also performed a of sensitivity analyses to ensure the of the and observed the same Finally, our study was not to differences in However, prior a association between treatment time and mortality in In a statewide linked data we that approximately 12% of all patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction presented without chest pain to emergency medical services responders. percent of ST-elevation myocardial infarction patients without chest pain did not receive prehospital and this was associated with longer times to reperfusion. Future efforts are needed to promote the use of prehospital to achieve more rapid identification of ST-elevation myocardial infarction patients with atypical presentations in the prehospital The author both and for their and and the of and the Carolina Medical for this
26
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2014 Update
Alan S. Go, Dariush Mozaffarian, Véronique L. Roger et al. · Circulation · 2013 · 5.2K citations · Full text
2013 ACCF/AHA Guideline for the Management of ST-Elevation Myocardial Infarction
Patrick T. O’Gara, Frederick G. Kushner, Deborah D. Ascheim et al. · Circulation · 2012 · 4.7K citations