Comparison of the Photoelectrochemical Behavior of H-Terminated and Methyl-Terminated Si(111) Surfaces in Contact with a Series of One-Electron, Outer-Sphere Redox Couples in CH<sub>3</sub>CN

Ronald L. Grimm, Matthew J. Bierman, Leslie E. O’Leary, Nicholas C. Strandwitz, Bruce S. Brunschwig, Nathan S. Lewis

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C · 2012 · 70 citations · 28 references

Concepts

Abstract

The photoelectrochemical behavior of methyl-terminated p-type and n-type Si(111) surfaces was determined in contact with a series of one-electron, outer-sphere, redox couples that span >1 V in the Nernstian redox potential, E (A/A – ), of the solution. The dependence of the current vs potential data, as well as of the open-circuit photovoltage, V oc, on E (A/A – ) was compared to the behavior of H-terminated p-type and n-type Si(111) surfaces in contact with these same electrolytes. For a particular E (A/A – ) value, CH 3 -terminated p-Si(111) electrodes showed lower V oc values than H-terminated p-Si(111) electrodes, whereas CH 3 -terminated n-Si(111) electrodes showed higher V oc values than H-terminated n-Si(111) electrodes. Under 100 mW cm –2 of ELH-simulated Air Mass 1.5 illumination, n-type H–Si(111) and CH 3 –Si(111) electrodes both demonstrated nonrectifying behavior with no photovoltage at very negative values of E (A/A – ) and produced limiting V oc values of >0.5 V at very positive values of E (A/A – ). Illuminated p-type H–Si(111) and CH 3 –Si(111) electrodes produced no photovoltage at positive values of E (A/A – ) and produced limiting V oc values in excess of 0.5 V at very negative values of E (A/A – ). In contact with CH 3 CN-octamethylferrocene +/0, differential capacitance vs potential experiments yielded a −0.40 V shift in flat-band potential for CH 3 -terminated n-Si(111) surfaces relative to H-terminated n-Si(111) surfaces. Similarly, in contact with CH 3 CN-1,1′-dicarbomethoxycobaltocene +/0, the differential capacitance vs potential data indicated a −0.25 V shift in the flat-band potential for CH 3 -terminated p-Si(111) electrodes relative to H-terminated p-Si(111) electrodes. The observed trends in V oc vs E (A/A – ), and the trends in the differential capacitance vs potential data are consistent with a negative shift in the interfacial dipole as a result of methylation of the Si(111) surface. The negative dipole shift is consistent with a body of theoretical and experimental comparisons of the behavior of CH 3 –Si(111) surfaces vs H–Si(111) surfaces, including density functional theory of the sign and magnitude of the surface dipole, photoemission spectroscopy in ultrahigh vacuum, the electrical behavior of Hg/Si contacts, and the pH dependence of the current–potential behavior of Si electrodes in contact with aqueous electrolytes.

References

28