Six theses on waste, value, and commons

Vinay Gidwani

Social & Cultural Geography · 2013 · 134 citations · 9 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Capitalist value theory originates from the enclosure of commons-as-waste and commoning practices that transform property, and these processes persist, positioning capitalist production as a necessity that marginalizes needs‑oriented value and casts people, places, and practices as waste. The study shows that waste, inherent to capital’s becoming, simultaneously represents capitalist value‑in‑waiting and an omnipresent dissipation logic that undermines capital’s legitimacy and existence.

Abstract

The origins of capitalist value theory lie in transformations of property through enclosure of 'commons-as-waste' and practices of 'commoning' that supported these. These processes, repeated with difference, remain with us. Capitalist value production becomes a structure of necessity in societies that are profit seeking rather than needs oriented; the history of capitalist value is one of the unrelenting attempts to subordinate needs-oriented forms of value production to its accumulative logic. In the process, it continuously casts certain people, places, and conducts as wasteful, superfluous, or residual. In short, capitalist value constantly battles to assert its normative superiority over and autonomy from other forms of value production that interweaves with it. Waste, immanent to capital's becoming-being, poses a jeopardy to capital accumulation: it is, on the one hand, capitalist value-in-waiting and on the other hand, it is an omnipresent logic of dissipation that evades or exceeds capital's dialectic, threatening its legitimacy and existence.

References

9