How Does It Work?

Unknown author(s)

Philosophy of the Social Sciences · 2004 · 501 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Mechanisms are the underlying processes that define how systems function, yet they are largely imperceptible and must be inferred to provide explanatory power. The article seeks to clarify what constitutes a mechanism, how mechanisms can be identified, and why understanding them is essential for scientific explanation and technological control. Identifying mechanisms fulfills both the desire for understanding and the requirement for control.

Abstract

This article addresses the following problems: What is a mechanism, how can it be discovered, and what is the role of the knowledge of mechanisms in scientific explanation and technological control? The proposed answers are these. A mechanism is one of the processes in a concrete system that makes it what it is — for example, metabolism in cells, interneuronal connections in brains, work in factories and offices, research in laboratories, and litigation in courts of law. Because mechanisms are largely or totally imperceptible, they must be conjectured. Once hypothesized they help explain, because a deep scientific explanation is an answer to a question of the form, “How does it work, that is, what makes it tick—what are its mechanisms?” Thus, by contrast with the subsumption of particulars under a generalization, an explanation proper consists in unveiling some lawful mechanism, as when political stability is explained by either coercion, public opinion manipulation, or democratic participation. Finding mechanisms satisfies not only the yearning for understanding, but also the need for control.

References

16