British colonialism and the criminalization of homosexuality

Enze Han, Joseph O’Mahoney

Cambridge Review of International Affairs · 2014 · 123 citations · 38 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Global variation in laws criminalizing homosexual conduct is largely attributed to British colonialism, a claim that has been recently examined. The study aims to evaluate the claim that British colonialism is responsible for the criminalization of homosexuality worldwide. Using a newly constructed dataset of 185 countries, the authors assess this claim. The analysis shows that British colonies are more likely to criminalize homosexuality, a result that persists after controlling for other factors, yet the evidence that colonialism systematically delayed decriminalization is weak.

Abstract

What explains the global variation in laws criminalizing homosexual conduct? Recent research has claimed that British colonialism is largely responsible for the criminalization of homosexuality around the world. This article utilizes a newly constructed dataset that includes up-to-date data on 185 countries to assess this claim. We find that British colonies are much more likely to have criminalization of homosexual conduct laws than other colonies or other states in general. This result holds after controlling for other variables that might be expected to influence the likelihood of repressive lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) rights legislation. However, we also find that the evidence in favour of the claim that British imperialism 'poisoned' societies against homosexuality is weak. British colonies do not systematically take longer to decriminalize homosexual conduct than other European colonies.

References

38