The bounds of smart decline: a foundational theory for planning shrinking cities

Justin B. Hollander, Jeremy Németh

Housing Policy Debate · 2011 · 324 citations · 56 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Economic decline has triggered widespread population shrinkage in U.S. cities, prompting debate over smart decline strategies such as those in Detroit and Cleveland, while noting that long‑term loss shares common physical processes and policy responses. The paper develops a foundational theory of smart decline grounded in ethical, equity, and social justice discussions and empirical observations of successful practice. The theory distinguishes top‑down policies originating from city leadership from bottom‑up initiatives driven by grassroots groups, drawing on case studies such as Youngstown and literature from Fainstein and Brindley.

Abstract

Abstract Economic decline has led to a new wave of population decline throughout the US, meaning more and more cities are shrinking. Growing interest in using smart decline principles to respond to shrinkage has been met with controversy in cities such as Detroit and Cleveland. This paper advances a foundational theory of smart decline that takes as its starting point discussions of ethics, equity, and social justice in the planning and political theory literature, but is well grounded in observations of successful smart decline practice. Keywords: abandoned propertyland use/zoningvacant landView correction statement:Erratum Acknowledgements Partial funding for this research was provided by University of Colorado Denver's Center for International Business Education and Research (CIBER). Notes 1While there are differences between a city losing population and housing units over three years and the kind of prolonged population and economic loss experienced by cities such as Detroit, Manchester, and Leipzig over decades, the basic physical processes and policy responses have much in common. 2Here we define "top-down" as any policies or plans that originate and are implemented from political and administrative leadership within a city government. This approach is in contrast to "bottom-up" policies that come from grassroots organizations or neighborhood groups with implementation duties shared across governmental and non-governmental organizations. 3Mr. Williams later became mayor of Youngstown. 4Details of this case are widely available but are drawn principally from Fainstein (2010) and Brindley et al. (1996).

References

56