Comparison of linear systems and finite difference flow‐routing techniques

Thomas N. Keefer

Water Resources Research · 1976 · 23 citations · 7 references

Concepts

Abstract

A single‐input linear system model and a multiple‐input linear system model are compared to a finite difference model. Comparisons are based on the ability of the models to predict discharge at the downstream end of a 24.14‐km reach of prismatic channel. Four types of channels and two slopes covering a wide range of conditions are evaluated. The single‐input model compares favorably in cases where flood wave celerity does not vary greatly with discharge. The multiple‐input model can be made to compare favorably in all cases. Linear model parameters cannot be set accurately without calibration, except in the case of rectangular channels. The single‐input model is approximately one sixth as costly as the finite difference model, and the multiple‐input model is approximately one half as costly for the conditions investigated.

References

7