American Political Science Review · 1978 · 33 citations · 12 references
LawConstitutional LawPolitical ScienceAmerican PoliticsFederalismSeparation Of PowersChecks And BalancesConstitutional ConventionsParty SystemsPolitical PowerSeparation Of Powers HistoryFederalism CritiqueSeparation Of Powers Critique
This article critically examines the commonly held proposition that Madison advocated separation of powers as a means of thwarting majority rule, or, conversely, of protecting identifiable minority interests. Rather, Madison's chief purpose in advancing the doctrine of separation of powers–one which was shared by the majority of his contemporaries–was to prevent governmental tyranny whose characteristic feature was seen as arbitrary and capricious rule resulting in government of men, not of laws. Many modern critics' analyses of the Madisonian model (most notably, Burns, Dahl, and advocates of a responsible party system) are seriously deficient because they fail to take into account this dimension of the model. Madison's writings, principally in The Federalist, as well as his remarks at the Philadelphia convention, clearly indicate that one of his central concerns was simultaneously to provide for protection against governmental tyranny and to guarantee popular control of government. This article examines in some detail certain critical aspects of this endeavor.
12
A Preface to Democratic Theory.
Feliks Gross, Robert A. Dahl · American Sociological Review · 1957 · 2.2K citations
Social Sciences, Political Science, Constitutional History +5
Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers
Caroline Robbins, M. J. C. Vile, William B. Gwyn et al. · The William and Mary Quarterly · 1968 · 390 citations
Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers
Carl J. Friedrich, M. J. C. Vile · The American Historical Review · 1968 · 266 citations