An Experimental Investigation of Spur Gear Efficiency

T. T. Petry-Johnson, Ahmet Kahraman, Neil Anderson, D. Chase

Journal of Mechanical Design · 2008 · 204 citations · 23 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The study develops a test methodology to measure spur gear efficiency under high‑speed, variable‑torque conditions and to quantify how module, surface roughness, and lubricant affect load‑dependent, load‑independent, and total power loss. A power‑circulating test machine operating up to 10,000 rpm and 700 kW, equipped with a precision torque measurement system, was used to test gears of two modules and two surface roughness levels in a dry‑sump jet‑lubricated environment with three lubricants. The tests revealed that mechanical mesh and total gearbox efficiencies vary with rotational speed and transmitted torque, leading to recommendations for gear module, surface roughness, and lubricant choice to improve efficiency.

Abstract

In this study, a test methodology was developed for the measurement of spur gear efficiency under high-speed and variable torque conditions. A power-circulating test machine was designed to operate at speeds to 10,000rpm and transmitted power levels to 700kW. A precision torque measurement system was implemented, and its accuracy and repeatability in measuring torque loss in the power loop was demonstrated. Tests were conducted on gears with two values of modules and two surface roughness levels, operating in a dry sump jet-lubrication environment with three different gear lubricants. These tests were used to quantify the influence of these parameters on both load-dependent (mechanical), load-independent (spin), and total power loss. Trends in mechanical gear mesh efficiency and total gearbox efficiency were discussed in terms of rotational speed and transmitted torque. Finally, recommendations were made for the design of spur gear pairs, surface roughness, and lubricant selection for improved efficiency.

References

23