Journal of American History · 2002 · 54 citations · 0 references
Public AffairsPublic PolicyAmerican PoliticsFundraisingPhilanthropyCorporate Grant ApplicationsFederal GrantsFoundation Grant ApplicationsFoundation GrantsFoundation ManagementFoundation SystemsCorporate Foundation GrantmakingFoundationFoundation FundingFoundation PhilanthropyFoundation StrategyFoundations HistoryPublic FoundationsPublic Investment Institutions
The high-profile philanthropy of Bill Gates and George Soros is evoking the era of John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie and the emergence of general-purpose foundations early in the twentieth century. Mark Dowie, a prize-winning, left-leaning journalist, thinks it is time to take stock of these important institutions, whose numbers and endowments have grown substantially. He is not impressed with what he finds. He characterizes foundations as cautious, conservative “drag anchors.” Grant dollars, Dowie says, have gone disproportionately to the elite professional classes, university-based scientists, and think-tank experts to pursue unimaginative work that perpetuates the status quo and with it the institutions that create wealth and, as it happens, more foundations. Dowie claims to have pored over foundation archives, but the collections are nowhere listed, and only a handful of documents from the Ford and Rockefeller foundations appear in the footnotes. He adds that he conducted over two hundred interviews, acknowledging by name scores of foundation executives, program directors, and others. Again, however, only fifteen interviewees are referenced in the notes (though one can understand the reluctance of some foundation officers to be identified with their comments). These lapses in the book's scholarly apparatus are compounded by some glaring errors. For example, he ascribes Ford Foundation presidencies they never had to George Kennan and Robert Hutchins, and he seems unaware that Jonas Salk died in 1995 or that the Lucille P. Markey Charitable Trust terminated in 1997.