Expert Systems · 2007 · 141 citations · 59 references
ComputingComputer ScienceArtificial IntelligenceKnowledge RepresentationLogicAutomated ReasoningClassification SchemesDeductive ReasoningExpert SystemsRule-based RepresentationCase-based Knowledge RepresentationCase-based ReasoningGeneral KnowledgeRule-based CategorizationRule-based Knowledge RepresentationRule-based Systems
Rule‑based and case‑based reasoning are widely used in intelligent systems, with rules encoding general knowledge and cases capturing specific experiences; their complementary strengths motivate hybrid approaches that mitigate each method’s shortcomings. The study introduces a new categorization scheme for hybrid rule‑based and case‑based reasoning by first outlining their complementary strengths and weaknesses and highlighting deficiencies in existing integration approaches. The authors develop a new categorization framework, critique current schemes, and illustrate it with representative approaches for each category.
Abstract: Rule‐based and case‐based reasoning are two popular approaches used in intelligent systems. Rules usually represent general knowledge, whereas cases encompass knowledge accumulated from specific (specialized) situations. Each approach has advantages and disadvantages, which are proved to be complementary to a large degree. So, it is well justified to combine rules and cases to produce effective hybrid approaches, surpassing the disadvantages of each component method. In this paper, we first present advantages and disadvantages of rule‐based and case‐based reasoning and show that they are complementary. We then discuss the deficiencies of existing categorization schemes for integrations of rule‐based and case‐based representations. To deal with these deficiencies, we introduce a new categorization scheme. Finally, we briefly present representative approaches for the final categories of our scheme.
59
J. R. Quinlan · Machine Learning · 1986 · 14.8K citations · Full text
J. R. Quinlan · Machine Learning · 1986 · 12.4K citations · Full text