The Review of Economics and Statistics · 1990 · 273 citations · 38 references
Natural SciencesEarth SciencesPetroleum EngineeringGeochemistryMineralogyPetroleum GeologyFuel DepletionMineral Resource AssessmentMineral WeatheringPetroleum GeochemistryResource DepletionLaboratory InvestigationsMineral Resource Depletion ModelsNatural Gas Depletion
Two implications of received theory are (1) mineral net prices rise at the riskless \ninterest rate, and (2) in-ground value is equal to the current net price. Both propositions are \nfalse. A correct theory has been joined to mistaken premises. \nMineral resources are inexhaustible. The economic problem is not the intertemporal \nallocation of a stock but coping with the cost of a flow of reserve accretions. Mineral scarcity \nand price are the uncertain fluctuating result of a tug-of-war between diminishing returns \nversus increasing knowledge. Hence minerals are risky assets. \nDevelopment cost, finding cost, and user cost (the penalty for development/production \ntoday instead of tomorrow) are all substitutes. Hence change in any one is a proxy for change in \nany other. Development cost is observable, and has been stable in many countries for pro- \nlonged periods. User cost was also stable in the USA. There is no sign of any pattern of gradual \ndepletion and rising cost. \nA simple model of an individual reservoir explains observed relations of value and \nprice. The rate of interest has both a positive and negative effect upon the rate of reservoir \ndepletion. The net effect of a change is therefore weak. \nExpropriation of low-cost oil fields, had they been operated independently to maximize \nvalue, would have led to drastic increases in depletion rates. The fact of decrease proves \ncollusive restriction of output to maintain prices.
38
The Economics of Exhaustible Resources
Harold Hotelling · Journal of Political Economy · 1931 · 4.3K citations