Journal of Religious Ethics · 2008 · 31 citations · 17 references
ArtsHistoryReligionComparative ReligionEthicsReligious EthicsComparative Religious EthicsCross-cultural EthicsMoral JudgmentNormative EthicsSocial EthicsComparative EthicsCross-cultural Ethical Decision MakingCross-cultural Moral JudgmentsCross-cultural Moral ReasoningMoral Reasoning Across CulturesNormative SystemsReligious Morality
ABSTRACT The most interesting and perilous issue at present in comparative religious ethics is comparative ethical judgment—when and how to judge others, if at all. There are understandable historical and conceptual reasons for the current tendency to prefer descriptive over normative work in comparative religious ethics. However, judging those we study is inescapable—it can be suppressed or marginalized but not eliminated. Therefore, the real question is how to judge others (and ourselves) well, not whether to judge. Instead of bringing supposedly universal moral scoring systems to bear on reified “traditions” and “cultures,” it would be better to focus on the precise details of particular practices, motifs, and theories in various settings, and compare them with an eye to substantive issues of current ethical concern.
17
Whose justice? Which rationality?
Choice Reviews Online · 1988 · 966 citations
Miranda Fricker, Martha C. Nussbaum · The Journal of Philosophy · 2000 · 866 citations
Distinguished Lecture: Anti Anti‐Relativism
Clifford Geertz · American Anthropologist · 1984 · 568 citations