The Sociological Review · 1998 · 235 citations · 28 references
Social SciencesEconomicsSociologyFeminist TheoryHousehold DemographySocial InequalityHousehold Decision-makingHousehold EconomicsHousehold EconomyHousehold Financial Decision-makingMarriageHousehold Bargaining PowerHousehold Decision-making PowerHousehold InequalityHousehold Power DynamicsIntra-household AllocationIntra-household Decision-makingIntra-household DynamicsIntrahousehold Power Relations
This paper addresses criticisms of a number of papers (Vogler and Pahl, 1993, 1994; Vogler, 1994) in which we attempted to explore the relationships between money, power and inequality within marriage. Subsequent criticisms have mainly centred around the concept of power that we used in those papers. It has been suggested that we either lacked a theory of power (Rottman, 1996) or that our conceptualisation of power as control over decision making was too limited (Shove, 1993). I would argue however, that while it was not made explicit in our original papers our findings point towards a more general theory of power in the household, namely to a modified version of Lukes' three dimensional model of power. While we initially conceptualised power as control over decision making (Lukes' first dimension of power) our findings also show the importance of ideological and cultural factors (Lukes' third dimension of power) as both a cause and a consequence of the allocative systems couples use to organise money within the household. More theoretically, I also suggest that discourses about money within the household may be part of, and operate in a similar way to discourses of decision making at the broader political level. It may therefore be possible to conceptualise the different ways of managing money within the household as mini political systems akin to different sorts of democracy at the broader political level, and with similar consequences for gender relations.
28
N. De Viggiani · UWE Research Repository (UWE Bristol) · 1995 · 1.3K citations · Full text
Choice Reviews Online · 1994 · 886 citations
The Social Meaning of Money: "Special Monies"
Viviana A. Zelizer · American Journal of Sociology · 1989 · 783 citations
Choice Reviews Online · 1992 · 490 citations