Agronomy Journal · 2013 · 550 citations · 75 references
AgricultureAgronomyCrop SciencesCrop ManagementCrop ModelingCropping SystemsYield EstimationYield PredictionAcceptable Parameter RangesAssumptions AnalysisConvergenceModel Assumptions AssessmentModel Fit ComparisonNonlinear RegressionNonlinear Regression ModelsResidual Analysis
Nonlinear regression models are essential for accurately representing crop and soil processes, yet fitting them is a complex, multi‑step procedure that demands careful attention to parameter estimation, model fit, and statistical assumptions. The authors aim to clarify this complex fitting process by presenting a stepwise flow diagram, detailed examples, and a library of 77 nonlinear functions for agricultural applications. Their methodology follows a seven‑step workflow—selecting candidate models, setting starting values, fitting, checking convergence and parameter estimates, choosing the best model, validating assumptions, and computing statistical descriptors—while also addressing feedback on variance homogeneity.
Nonlinear regression models are important tools because many crop and soil processes are better represented by nonlinear than linear models. Fitting nonlinear models is not a single‐step procedure but an involved process that requires careful examination of each individual step. Depending on the objective and the application domain, different priorities are set when fitting nonlinear models; these include obtaining acceptable parameter estimates and a good model fit while meeting standard assumptions of statistical models. We propose steps in fitting nonlinear models as described by a flow diagram and discuss each step separately providing examples and updates on procedures used. The following steps are considered: (i) choose candidate models, (ii) set starting values, (iii) fit models, (iv) check convergence and parameter estimates, (v) find the “best” model among competing models, (vi) check model assumptions (residual analysis), and (vii) calculate statistical descriptors and confidence intervals. The associated feedback mechanisms are also addressed (i.e., model variance homogeneity). In particular, we emphasize the first step (choose candidate models) by providing an extensive library of nonlinear functions (77 equations with the associated parameter meanings) and examples of typical applications in agriculture. We hope that this contribution will clarify some of the difficulties and confusion with the task of using nonlinear models.
75