Comparison of Clinical Assessment with APACHE II for Predicting Mortality Risk in Patients Admitted to a Medical Intensive Care Unit

James A. Kruse, Mary Thill-Baharozian, R W Carlson

Survey of Anesthesiology · 1989 · 18 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Comment There have been numerous criticisms leveled at each of the scoring systems used in critical care. The criticisms are usually leveled at the fact that these systems either include or exclude certain favored items of the individual leveling the criticism. I do not care to enter the arena of specificity. Instead, I have more global thoughts about these scoring systems. While the APACHE II scoring system appean to have some value as a predicting tool, it does not appear to be better than even an inexperienced physician's in-training. It certainly is another tool, but I find that none of these predicting scoring systems are ever used to provide, alter, or withdraw treatment. Therefore, the APACHE and other like scoring systems series as wonderful computer model exercises only. William D. Owens, M.D.