2014 · 29 citations · 10 references
EngineeringInformation SystemsSystems EngineeringEnterprise SystemsEnterprise Systems EngineeringSystems DesignEnterprise TransformationInformation Systems IntegrationEnterprise Systems ArchitectureSocio-technical Systems
Enterprise Engineering is the purposeful design of enterprises and their transformative activities, drawing on information systems and organizational science, and would benefit from diverse research approaches to study socio‑technical systems. The paper analyzes 115 EE research papers from four conferences (PRET, EEWC, MCIS, ECIS) between 2009 and 2013 to examine research paradigms and topics, and aims to spark debate on adopting alternative paradigms and studying social aspects. The authors surveyed 115 EE papers from four conferences (PRET, EEWC, MCIS, ECIS) between 2009 and 2013 to assess research paradigms and topic composition. The analysis revealed that EE research overemphasizes technical focus and the functionalist paradigm, underinvestigating social aspects and interpretive approaches, indicating a need for more balanced research to advance EE theory.
Enterprise Engineering (EE) is about purposeful design of enterprises and their transformative activities. It is an interdisciplinary domain, which draws largely on information systems and organizational science. Not unlike these fields, EE would benefit from a variety of research approaches to study the engineering of socio-technical systems. To analyze the prevalence of different research paradigms and the composition of research topics in the EE field, we examined 115 research papers in the field as presented in four pertinent conferences in 2009–2013: the Practice-Driven Research on Enterprise Transformation (PRET), Enterprise Engineering Working Conference (EEWC) as well as relevant tracks in the Mediterranean Conference on Information Systems (MCIS) and in the European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS). As per this analysis, the social aspect seems to be under-investigated and the interpretive paradigm under-represented in the EE research, while there seems to be a bias towards technical focus and the functionalist paradigm. The analysis ascertained the need for further evolvement of the EE discipline through more attention to social aspects and a more balanced variety of research approaches. We view that this will balance the course of advancing EE theories with the integration of gathered insights. With this paper, we want to instill a debate on the need for alternative research paradigms and for research on social aspects in the field of EE.
10
The Emergence of Interpretivism in IS Research
Geoff Walsham · Information Systems Research · 1995 · 1.1K citations