Space and Culture · 2008 · 13 citations · 24 references
LawComparative LawCriminal LawComparative JurisprudenceComparative Legal SystemsCriminal ProcedureDispute ResolutionEmpirical Study Of CourtsJudicial BehaviorPlea BargainingPlea NegotiationsTrial ProcedureAsymmetry In Courtroom InteractionBehavioral Analysis Of JudgesComparative Court BehaviorComparative CourtsEpistemic FrameworksState Trial CourtsTrial Court Decision-making
To grasp criminal courts as truth spots, one needs to go beyond their symbolic applications to consider their interactional and epistemic implications. In this study, the authors compare the English Crown Court, German District Court, and U.S. State Court as “places on display” and as “places denied.” These perspectives comment on the courts in light of their different interaction orders and their different positions in knowledge processes. For the latter, the authors utilize Knorr's taxonomy of laboratory—experiment relations. The article arrives at one basic distinction: the procedural replacement of trial hearings by deal-oriented plea bargaining in the U.S. context. In contrast, the English and the German courts involve a preference for trial hearings and for fully developed cases, which, however, does not forbid but encourage forms of trial-oriented plea bargain.
24
Epistemic cultures: how the sciences make knowledge
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 3.4K citations
The Process Is the Punishment: Handling Cases in a Lower Criminal Court
Malcolm M Feeley · Michigan Law Review · 1980 · 741 citations
Law, Criminal Law, Criminology +12
The House of Experiment in Seventeenth-Century England
Steven Shapin · Isis · 1988 · 561 citations · Full text