Identification and Robustness with Contaminated and Corrupted Data

Joël L. Horowitz, Charles F. Manski

Econometrica · 1995 · 341 citations · 2 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Robust estimation often fails to identify population parameters, making point estimation problematic, especially when data may be contaminated or corrupted. The study develops robust estimators that are insensitive to data errors and shows that, under typical error models, previously unidentified population parameters can be bounded. The authors present a method for estimating bounds and illustrate it with an application. The study finds that bounds on previously unidentified parameters can be obtained, offering information unavailable from robust estimation, such as finite bounds on the population mean under contaminated sampling.

Abstract

Robust estimation aims at developing point estimators that are not highly sensitive to errors in the data. However, the population parameters of interest are not identified under the assumptions of robust estimation, so the rationale for point estimation is not apparent. This paper shows that under error models used in robust estimation, unidentified population parameters can often be bounded. The bounds provide information that is not available in robust estimation. For example, it is possible to obtain finite bounds on the population mean under contaminated sampling. A method for estimating the bounds is given and illustrated with an application. It is argued that when the data may be contaminated or corrupted, estimating the bounds is more natural than attempting point estimation of unidentified parameters

References

2