Agricultural Systems · 2013 · 213 citations · 29 references
AgricultureAgroecologyAgricultural DevelopmentAgroecosystem EcologyRural DevelopmentAgroecosystem ResilienceAgroecosystem StabilityEcosystem ResilienceRural LivelihoodsAgroecological TransitionsAgroecosystem DiversityFarming System ResilienceFarming Systems AnalysisResilient Farming SystemsRural Livelihood DevelopmentSmallholder FarmersSmallholder Livelihoods
Agroecosystem dynamics stem from diverse livelihood strategies reacting to shifting ecological, demographic, and market contexts, producing non‑linear, irreversible, and hysteretic patterns within a nested hierarchy of constraints that must be addressed by policy and market interventions to enable desirable system shifts. The study applies resilience theory to African smallholder agriculture by examining complex system dynamics and testing three hypotheses on livelihood diversity as alternative regimes, transformability outcomes, and context‑driven changes through case studies. Kenyan households exhibit diversity as alternative regimes via hysteretic, non‑reversible dynamics; in northern Cameroon, diversity arises from divergent pathways implying radical past transformations; East African agroecosystems reveal elusive, site‑specific thresholds indicating potential tipping points, underscoring the need for systematic context categorization.
Aiming to translate resilience thinking theory into farming systems design practice, this paper examines fundamental properties of complex systems dynamics and their relation with the mechanisms that govern resilience and transformability in African smallholder agriculture. Agroecosystems dynamics emerge from the aggregation of diverse livelihood strategies in response to changes in the agroecosystem context, and are characterised by non-linearity, irreversibility, convergence/divergence and hysteresis. I examine a number of case studies from Africa to verify three guiding hypotheses in connection to the diversity of rural livelihood strategies: (1) diversity as alternative system regimes; (2) diversity as the result of transformability; (3) diversity determined by changing agricultural contexts. The hierarchy of constraints that determine the space for manoeuvring in agroecosystems is described through the analogy of the Matryoshka nesting dolls: each system level confines and is confined by their immediate sub- and supra-systems. Agricultural contexts, as defined by agro-ecological potential, demography and market connectivity are also dynamic and their trajectory can be described as shifts across stability domains. An example from Kenya shows that household diversity can be described as alternative system regimes, through hysteretic rather than continuous, reversible models. In some particular cases diversity emerges from divergent pathways that may have implied radical transformations in the past, as shown here for rural livelihoods in northern Cameroun. A comparative analysis of East African agroecosystems shows that thresholds in specific variables that may point to the existence of possible tipping points are rather elusive and largely site specific, requiring systematic categorisation of agricultural contexts. While agroecology needs to provide the knowledge base for the ecological intensification of smallholder landscapes, policy and market developments are needed to deal with the Matryoshka effect – or with interactions that are presumably panarchical in certain cases. Desirable shifts in farming systems can only be stimulated by working on both ends simultaneously.
29
Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems
C. S. Holling · Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics · 1973 · 17.8K citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Biology, Ecology +8
Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability in Social-ecological Systems
Brian Walker, C. S. Holling, Stephen R. Carpenter et al. · Ecology and Society · 2004 · 7.5K citations · Full text
Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems
Marten Scheffer, Jonathan A. Foley, Carl Folke et al. · Nature · 2001 · 7.3K citations
A hierarchical concept of ecosystems
Brian A. Maurer · Trends in Ecology & Evolution · 1987 · 1.2K citations