Review of Policy Research · 1999 · 354 citations · 23 references
Public AffairsPublic AdministrationPublic PolicyEnvironmental Decision-makingEnvironmental GovernancePolitical ParticipationCitizen ParticipationCivic ParticipationParticipatory Decision-makingParticipatory GovernanceParticipatory PolicymakingPublic ParticipationMechanismsParticipation In Public Decision-makingParticipatory Environmental Decision-makingPublic Participation FrameworksPublic Participation In Decision-makingPublic Sector Values
Public participation in environmental decision‑making is increasingly emphasized, yet few evaluation approaches exist to determine what benefits are achieved. The article proposes a framework that evaluates participatory processes by measuring six social goals. The framework defines six social goals—educating the public, incorporating public values, improving decision quality, fostering trust, reducing conflict, and cost‑effectiveness—and links each to specific participatory mechanisms. The study concludes by outlining future research directions based on the proposed framework.
ABSTRACT The need to increase public participation in environmental decision‐making is receiving renewed attention at all levels of government. However, there are few approaches to evaluating these processes that address the question: What are we getting from public participation? This article proposes one way to answer this question using a framework that evaluates the outcomes of participatory processes using a set of “social” goals. These social goals are: 1) educating the public; 2) incorporating public values, assumptions, and preferences into decision making; 3) increasing the substantive quality of decisions; 4) fostering trust in institutions; 5) reducing conflict; and 6) making decisions cost‐effectively. Although these goals apply to public participation writ large, there are a limited number of formalized mechanisms available to public agencies for involving the public. The article matches these six social goals to the participatory mechanisms by which they might be achieved. It concludes with areas for further research suggested by the framework.
23
Bowling Alone: America's Declining Social Capital
Robert D. Putnam · Journal of democracy · 1995 · 14K citations
Perceived Risk, Trust, and Democracy
Paul Slovic · Risk Analysis · 1993 · 1.9K citations
The Fifth Branch: Science Advisors as Policymakers
Ronald Andersen · JAMA · 1991 · 608 citations