Hispanic American Historical Review · 2000 · 42 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesGender StudiesHistoryFeminist TheorySocial HistoryWomen's StudiesColonial SexualityGender And FamilyGender IdentityGender In Postcolonial ContextsMarriagePersonal IdentityColonial Family FormationElite IdentityGender In Colonial HistoryGender In Latin AmericaMultigenerational Family DynamicsSexuality In Colonial HistorySpanish ColonialismWomen's Identity Formation
For those of us who have been following Ann Twinam’s work on honor, this book has been eagerly awaited and does not disappoint. Indeed, it goes well beyond issues of honor to explore in detail family dynamics among the colonial elite and Bourbon social policy, all in a clear and engaging style.In addition to a thorough introduction and conclusion, the book is organized into two substantial parts. In the first, Twinam takes the original approach of exploring the experiences of illegitimates and their families at each stage of the life cycle. In addition to providing unusually detailed glimpses into the private lives of the colonial elite, she uses her evidence to contribute to analyses of honor, patriarchy, and the shifting divisions between public and private. In previously published articles, she demonstrated how elite women could maintain public reputations of honor by keeping pregnancies secret and not raising their own children. Here she extends that notion of multiple identities, which were not necessarily aligned, to the children who had a “natal status” (as legitimate, natural, spurious, or bastard), a “baptismal status” (which included the additional categories of expósito and unknown parentage), a private familial status, and a public social status. Twinam also provides one of the few explorations available on colonial fathers, asserting that extramarital affairs had no affect on their honor but might weigh on their consciences.The next part of the book moves from elite families to Spanish bureaucrats in an insightful examination of how the laws of legitimation were applied over the course of the eighteenth century. In this section, Twinam presents significant findings on differences among geographical regions and change over time. From the vantage point of the colonies, attempts to preserve traditional hierarchies provoked an increase in petitions for legitimation from those who found themselves facing tightened exclusions from public offices, with the greatest prejudice occurring in the larger Caribbean region and the least in the Andes and Central America. Ultimately, the bureaucrats on the Council of Indies supported the goals of the colonial elite by granting legitimation primarily to those who had already passed as honorable and were socially well-connected. Along the way, nevertheless, Twinam perceptively traces an attempt at social engineering by mid-level Bourbon officials. In the first half of the eighteenth century, they approved the petitions of the few who applied and paid the necessary fees, regardless of their situations. By the middle of the century, however, officials began requesting more thorough documentation of petitioners’ actual natal and baptismal status and increasingly turned down the applications by the children of priests and adulterous parents on moral grounds. Their incipient attempts to discourage promiscuity by suggesting that parents automatically legitimate their own children through marriage were vetoed by higher authorities. Nevertheless, these bureaucrats in turn blunted the radical potential of a 1794 decree granting honor to all expósitos by failing to issue such applicants confirmations of their legitimation.Twinam’s analysis is backed up by impressive archival research. The bulk of her evidence comes from the 244 petitions (more than half of them complete) for legitimation (gracias al sacar) which she painstakingly unearthed from uncatalogued sections of the Archive of the Indies. In addition, she tracked down additional information on the applicants from wills, professional dossiers, and lawsuits in local archives throughout Spanish America. These cases provide her rich material on the deliberations of bureaucrats and the attitudes of the colonial elite, but readers should keep in mind that her findings apply only to a small if influential segment of the population. Twinam’s book is too long to use with most undergraduates, but given the breadth of its themes and cogent arguments it deserves a wide readership among scholars and graduate students.