International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making · 2013 · 11 citations · 19 references
BusinessDecision SciencesDecision AnalysisDecision MakingMulti-criteria Decision MakingAlternative RankingBayesian Decision TheoryCriteria SelectionDecision-making Under UncertaintyMulti-criteria Decision AnalysisRanking ProblemsAnalytic Hierarchy ProcessCriteria PrioritizationCross-validationDiscrepancy MeasuresE-participationHierarchical Decision ModelsMulticriteria Decision AnalysisPrioritization
This work extends the AHP-Bayesian Prioritization procedure proposed by the authors for a local context (a single criterion) to a global context (a hierarchy) and presents a taxonomy of criteria that contribute to the ranking of the alternatives. In this global context, the paper defines and characterizes: (i) the influence of a criterion in the final prioritization of the alternatives by means of cross-validation techniques; (ii) its degree of discordance with the rest of the criteria of the hierarchy utilizing new discrepancy measures; (iii) its relevance in the final decision. Along with the taxonomy and its corresponding methodology, the paper introduces new decisional tools for the establishment of the classification and demonstrates their use from a cognitive perspective (knowledge extraction) whilst paying special attention to the resolution of the P.α and P.γ problems. The proposed methodology is illustrated by a case study on an e-participation process developed for the Zaragoza City Council (Spain) and implemented by the Zaragoza Multicriteria Decision Making Group.
19
On a short-coming of Saaty's method of analytic hierarchies
Valerie Belton, Tony Gear · Omega · 1983 · 908 citations
FAMCDM: A fusion approach of MCDM methods to rank multiclass classification algorithms
Yi Peng, Gang Kou, Wang Guoxun et al. · Omega · 2011 · 212 citations