Coercive interactions in a psychiatric emergency room

Charles W. Lidz, Edward P. Mulvey, R.P. Arnold, Nancy Bennett, Brenda L. Kirsch

Behavioral Sciences & the Law · 1993 · 57 citations · 8 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract This paper describes the prevalence of coercive and non‐coercive efforts to influence patients' admission decisions in a psychiatric emergency room. The findings are based on previously collected transcripts of the interaction between patients and families and emergency room staff in 405 cases. Although a significant percentage of the patients were involuntarily admitted, otherwise the most prominent pressures were efforts by attending physicians to persuade patients about what would be the most appropriate disposition. However, a detailed qualitative analysis of the interaction suggest that the clinical staffs power to commit patients against their will affects the way all parties interpret the staffs ‘persuasion’ in such a way that it may be understood as quite coercive.

References

8