Exploring Farmers' Cultural Resistance to Voluntary Agri‐environmental Schemes

Rob J.F. Burton, Carmen Kuczera, Gérald Schwarz

Sociologia Ruralis · 2008 · 579 citations · 59 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Voluntary agri‑environmental programmes in Europe rarely change conventional farmers’ attitudes toward productivist agriculture. This study investigates why such programmes fail to shift attitudes, using case studies from Hessen, Germany and Aberdeenshire, Scotland. The authors construct a conceptual framework grounded in Bourdieu’s notions of capital to compare the symbolic capital generated by farming activities with that of conservation work. The study finds that voluntary agri‑environmental schemes return little symbolic capital because prescribed practices and designated areas prevent farmers from demonstrating skilled role performance and inhibit embodied cultural capital, and suggests that entrepreneurial, production‑target based schemes may better change long‑term behaviour.

Abstract

Abstract Studies throughout Europe have suggested that voluntary agri‐environmental programmes often engender very little change in attitudes towards productivist agriculture among conventional farming communities. This study examines why this may be so, using case studies from Hessen, Germany and Aberdeenshire, Scotland. By constructing a conceptual framework based on Bourdieu's notions of capital we explore how farming activities are able to generate symbolic capital, and compare this with the symbolic value of conservation work. We find that voluntary agri‐environmental work returns little symbolic capital to farmers as, by prescribing management practices and designating specific areas for agri‐environmental work, such schemes fail to allow farmers to develop or demonstrate skilled role performance – thus inhibiting the development of embodied cultural capital. We conclude by suggesting that entrepreneurial production‐target based agri‐environmental schemes may be ultimately more effective in changing long‐term behaviour.

References

59