Contributions to Indian Sociology · 2010 · 33 citations · 8 references
LawCriminal LawCriminologyJudicial ReviewMediationTheory Of JusticeCourt TestimonyJudicial BehaviorWitness ExaminationCourt PrecedentCourtroom CultureCourtroom NarrativesCourtroom Testimony AnalysisOut-of-court StatementsPower In Courtroom Interaction
People in India are strongly oriented toward litigation, yet the flow of cases does not reflect a fixed preference, suggesting that court attendance may be a first choice later abandoned for private compromise. The study aims to demonstrate how nonofficial conciliation can unsettle evidence rules in criminal proceedings. Using ethnography of a Himachal Pradesh district court case, the authors show that prosecution witnesses often deny prior police statements before the judge. The study finds that despite the court system's centrality, case flow does not indicate a fixed preference for litigation over other dispute resolution methods.
This article examines the argument that people in India are strongly oriented towards litigation in court as against other forms of negotiation or advising. In spite of the centrality of the court system to Indian public life, the flow of cases arriving at court does not reflect any such fixed preference. Going to court may simply be a choice which the parties make in the first instance, but which will eventually be abandoned in favour of private forms of compromise. By drawing on the ethnography of a court case followed in a district court of Himachal Pradesh, this contribution will show how even in serious criminal cases where no private compromise is allowed, it often happens that all the prosecution witnesses deny before the judge what they are supposed to have previously stated to the police. The analysis of court interactions and out-of-court narratives will show how nonofficial forms of conciliation may internally unsettle the rules of evidence followed in criminal proceedings.
8
An Anthropologist Among the Historians, and Other Essays.
C. J. Fuller, Bernard Cohn · Man · 1991 · 459 citations
The Anthropology of Justice: Law as Culture in Islamic Society.
Sally Falk Moore, Lawrence Rosen · Man · 1990 · 351 citations
Some Notes on Law and Change in North India
Bernard Cohn · Economic Development and Cultural Change · 1959 · 111 citations
Law, Public Law, Lawmaking +8
gender, power, and legal pluralism: Rajasthan, India
Erin P. Moore · American Ethnologist · 1993 · 68 citations