Acid Fracturing or Proppant Fracturing in Carbonate Formation? A Rock Mechanic's View

Abstract

Abstract Acid fracturing is performed to improve well productivity in acid-soluble formations such as limestone, dolomite, and chalk. Hydrochloric acid is generally used to create an etched fracture, which is the main mechanism for maintaining the fracture open during the life of a well. Proppant fracturing is an alternative option that has been applied in carbonate formations. In certain areas, proppant fracturing has been used as a standard stimulation method for carbonate formations. There is no quantitative method to provide an answer of whether acid fracturing or proppant fracturing is an appropriate stimulation method for a given carbonate formation. In proppant fracturing, proppant is used to sustain the effect of the minimum horizontal stress from closing the fracture. In acid fracturing the etched, non-smooth, surface with sufficient roughness should leave open channels upon closing. The effect of elastic, plastic, and creeping deformations in acid fracturing and the proppant crushing and embedment in proppant facturing, on reducing fracture permeability is investigated. The viscous effect, creeping, is a slow displacement that incurred over a long period of time. The creeping effect on fracture closure following an acid fracturing treatment is demonstrated in this paper. Laboratory experiments have been performed to simulate acid and proppant fracturing treatments. The effect of elastic, plastic and viscoelastic rock behavior on fracture conductivity was studied for acid and proppant fracturing treatments, using full core samples. Comparison of acid vs. proppant fracturing conductivity in carbonate formation is also presented.