Annals of Science · 1983 · 31 citations · 48 references
Life SciencesBiologyGeneticsClassical GeneticsCytogeneticsEvolutionary TheoryAneuploidyChromosome BiologyChromosome StructureStructural Chromosome AbnormalitiesChromosomal InheritanceHistory Of GeneticsTemperament
Summary Bateson's belated acceptance of the chromosome theory came in two main stages, and was permanent, although he retained to the end reservations about some implications and extensions of the theory. Coleman's attempt to explain Bateson's resistance in terms of his conservative mode of thought is critically examined, and rejected: the attributes Coleman assigns to Bateson are all either inappropriate, or irrelevant to chromosome theory, or both. Instead, the diverse factors which contributed to Bateson's resistance are enumerated and discussed. These include deficiencies in the evidence then available to support the theory; embryological difficulties; Bateson's aversion to microscopy combined with the lack of a close colleague skilled in cytology; his iconoclastic temperament, and the fact that he found T. H. Morgan, the leader of the Drosophila school, an uncongenial personality. Taken together, these factors suffice to account for his resistance. Bateson's position is contrasted with that of the other most eminent opponent, W. Johannsen, whose organismic outlook was the main obstacle to acceptance.
48
Sex Limited Inheritance in <i>Drosophila</i>
T. H. Morgan · Science · 1910 · 611 citations
Life Sciences, Biology, Entomology +13
Sex-linked inheritance in Drosophila
T. H. Morgan, Calvin B. Bridges · Carnegie Institution of Washington eBooks · 1916 · 607 citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Entomology, Genetics +17
Mendel's Principles of Heredity
Nature · 1913 · 528 citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Biology, Genetics +8
Resistance by Scientists to Scientific Discovery
Bernard Barber · Science · 1961 · 481 citations
The Measurement of Linkage in Heredity.
Journal of the American Medical Association · 1951 · 475 citations · Full text