Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 2008 · 401 citations · 33 references
Parasite InteractionsMalariaImmunologyCommunity EcologyInterdisciplinary LensImmune SystemEcological RulesHelminthologyParasitologyHost-pathogen InteractionsHost-parasite RelationshipAllergyPathogenesisParasite ControlSoil-transmitted HelminthiasisMicrobiologyHelminth InfectionHost ResistanceMedicine
Coinfection by multiple parasite species has significant epidemiological and clinical implications, yet the direction and magnitude of effects vary widely and no general explanatory framework exists, though community ecology offers potential for such analysis. The study meta‑analyses 54 mouse experiments to determine whether basic ecological rules govern coinfection outcomes across diverse parasite taxa. The authors combined resource‑based (bottom‑up) and predator‑based (top‑down) control mechanisms to determine microparasite population size in helminth‑coinfected hosts. Coinfection reduced microparasite density via bottom‑up control when an anemia‑causing helminth paired with a red‑blood‑cell‑dependent microparasite, but impaired top‑down immune control by suppressing IFN‑γ, leading to explosive microparasite growth when helminths neither limit resources nor modulate IFN‑γ, thereby revealing simple ecological rules governing coinfection.
Coinfection of a host by multiple parasite species has important epidemiological and clinical implications. However, the direction and magnitude of effects vary considerably among systems, and, until now, there has been no general framework within which to explain this variation. Community ecology has great potential for application to such problems in biomedicine. Here, metaanalysis of data from 54 experiments on laboratory mice reveals that basic ecological rules govern the outcome of coinfection across a broad spectrum of parasite taxa. Specifically, resource-based ("bottom-up") and predator-based ("top-down") control mechanisms combined to determine microparasite population size in helminth-coinfected hosts. Coinfection imposed bottom-up control (resulting in decreased microparasite density) when a helminth that causes anemia was paired with a microparasite species that requires host red blood cells. At the same time, coinfection impaired top-down control of microparasites by the immune system: the greater the helminth-induced suppression of the inflammatory cytokine interferon (IFN)-gamma, the greater the increase in microparasite density. These results suggest that microparasite population growth will be most explosive when underlying helminths do not impose resource limitations but do strongly modulate IFN-gamma responses. Surprisingly simple rules and an ecological framework within which to analyze biomedical data thus emerge from analysis of this dataset. Through such an interdisciplinary lens, predicting the outcome of coinfection may become tractable.
33
The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results.
Robert Rosenthal · Psychological Bulletin · 1979 · 8.4K citations
THE META-ANALYSIS OF RESPONSE RATIOS IN EXPERIMENTAL ECOLOGY
Larry V. Hedges, Jessica Gurevitch, Peter S. Curtis · Ecology · 1999 · 4.3K citations