Journal of Biological Chemistry · 2003 · 76 citations · 17 references
Life SciencesBiochemistryMolecular BiologyEnzyme MechanismEnzymologyStructural BiologyCatalytic MechanismsCatalytic Residue FunctionEnzyme FunctionEnzyme InhibitionEnzyme KineticsStructural EnzymologyDimethylallyl Diphosphate BiosynthesisEnzyme Catalytic MechanismIrreversible Covalent InhibitorsIsomerase CatalysisIsopentenyl Diphosphate BiosynthesisIsopentenyl Diphosphate IsomeraseTransition State Analogue BindingTransition State Analogues
Isopentenyl diphosphate (IPP):dimethylallyl diphosphate (DMAPP) isomerase is a key enzyme in the biosynthesis of isoprenoids. The reaction involves protonation and deprotonation of the isoprenoid unit and proceeds through a carbocationic transition state. Analysis of the crystal structures (2 Å) of complexes ofEscherichia coli IPP·DMAPPs isomerase with a transition state analogue (N,N-dimethyl-2-amino-1-ethyl diphosphate) and a covalently attached irreversible inhibitor (3,4-epoxy-3-methyl-1-butyl diphosphate) indicates that Glu-116, Tyr-104, and Cys-67 are involved in the antarafacial addition/elimination of protons during isomerization. This work provides a new perspective about the mechanism of the reaction.1NFS1NFZ Isopentenyl diphosphate (IPP):dimethylallyl diphosphate (DMAPP) isomerase is a key enzyme in the biosynthesis of isoprenoids. The reaction involves protonation and deprotonation of the isoprenoid unit and proceeds through a carbocationic transition state. Analysis of the crystal structures (2 Å) of complexes ofEscherichia coli IPP·DMAPPs isomerase with a transition state analogue (N,N-dimethyl-2-amino-1-ethyl diphosphate) and a covalently attached irreversible inhibitor (3,4-epoxy-3-methyl-1-butyl diphosphate) indicates that Glu-116, Tyr-104, and Cys-67 are involved in the antarafacial addition/elimination of protons during isomerization. This work provides a new perspective about the mechanism of the reaction.1NFS1NFZ isopentenyl diphosphate dimethylallyl diphosphate isomerase N,N-dimethyl-2-amino-1-ethyl diphosphate 3,4-epoxy-3-methyl-1-butyl diphosphate Isopentenyl diphosphate (IPP)1:dimethylallyl diphosphate (DMAPP) isomerase (EC 5.3.3.2) catalyzes the rearrangement of IPP (Scheme FS1, 1) to its electrophilic allylic isomer DMAPP (2). This is a mandatory activation step of the isoprenoid unit for subsequent prenyl transfer reactions in isoprenoid biosynthesis. Isomerization of the carbon-carbon double bond in IPP involves an antarafacial (1Cornforth J.W. Popjak G. Methods Enzymol. 1969; 15: 359-371Google Scholar, 3Clifford K. Cornforth J.W. Mallaby R. Phillips G.T. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1971; : 1699-1700Google Scholar) transposition of hydrogen by a proton addition-elimination mechanism (1Cornforth J.W. Popjak G. Methods Enzymol. 1969; 15: 359-371Google Scholar, 2Poulter C.D. Rilling H.C. Porter J.W. Porter S.L. Biosynthesis of Isoprenoid Compounds. 1. John Wiley and Sons, New York1981: 162-209Google Scholar). During the reaction, a proton is added to the re-face of the double bond in IPP, and there-proton at C2 is removed (3Clifford K. Cornforth J.W. Mallaby R. Phillips G.T. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1971; : 1699-1700Google Scholar). In eukaryotes, IPP is synthesized by the mevalonate pathway and is the exclusive product from phosphorylation and decarboxylation of mevalonic acid. IPP isomerase activity is an essential enzyme for these organisms. In many bacteria and in plant chloroplasts, IPP and DMAPP are both synthesized from 4-hydroxydimethylallyl diphosphate by the methylerythritol phosphate pathway (4Hoeffler J.F. Hemmerlin A. Grosdemange-Billard C. Bach T.J. Rohmer M. Biochem. J. 2002; 366: 573-583Google Scholar). Although IPP isomerase is often found in these bacteria, it is not essential. Multiple sequence alignments indicate that Escherichia coli IPP isomerase is related to the eukaryotic enzymes (5Hahn F.M. Hurlburt A.P. Poulter C.D. J. Bacteriol. 1999; 181: 4499-4504Google Scholar). In addition, a combination of gas chromatography/mass spectrometry and NMR studies with labeled IPP showed that the stereochemistry for the reversible introduction and removal of a proton at C2 during interconversion of IPP and DMAPP is the same for E. coli IPP isomerase and the eukaryotic enzymes (6Leyes A. Baker J.A. Hahn F.M. Poulter C.D. Chem. Commun. 1999; : 717-718Google Scholar). Several lines of evidence support the protonation/deprotonation mechanism shown in SchemeFS1. These include proton exchange measurements (7Street I.P. Christensen D.J. Poulter C.D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990; 112: 8577-8578Google Scholar), decreased reactivity for a fluorinated analogue of DMAPP, potent noncovalent inhibition by ammonium analogues of the putative carbocationic intermediate (8Reardon J.E. Abeles R.H. Biochemistry. 1986; 25: 5609-5616Google Scholar, 9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar), and irreversible inhibition by mechanism-based inhibitors containing epoxide moieties (9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar, 10Poulter C.D. Muelhbacher M. Davis D.R. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989; 111: 3740-3742Google Scholar, 11Lu X.J. Christensen D.J. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1992; 31: 9955-9960Google Scholar). Based on the antarafacial stereochemistry for protonation/deprotonation, it has been proposed that IPP isomerase has two active-site bases located on opposite faces of the allylic moiety defined by C2-C3-C4 in IPP. One of these bases is in the conjugate acid form and protonates the double bond. The other assists with the subsequent elimination of a proton (9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar). Reardon and Abeles (8Reardon J.E. Abeles R.H. Biochemistry. 1986; 25: 5609-5616Google Scholar) presented evidence for involvement of a thiol group during catalysis. The thiol group at Cys-139 was later identified as a catalytic-site residue in yeast IPP isomerase by covalent modification using epoxide (11Lu X.J. Christensen D.J. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1992; 31: 9955-9960Google Scholar) and allylic fluoride (12Street I.P. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1990; 29: 7531-7538Google Scholar) analogues of IPP. This residue corresponds to Cys-67 in E. coli IPP isomerase. Replacement of Cys-139 with serine by site-directed mutagenesis gave a catalytically compromised protein that was covalently modified at Glu-207 upon incubation with 3-(fluoromethyl)-3-butenyl diphosphate (13Street I.P. Coffman H.R. Baker J.A. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1994; 33: 4212-4217Google Scholar). Kinetic studies showed that an E207Q yeast mutant was also catalytically compromised (13Street I.P. Coffman H.R. Baker J.A. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1994; 33: 4212-4217Google Scholar). This residue corresponds to Glu-116 inE. coli IPP isomerase. The three-dimensional structure of E. coli IPP isomerase was recently solved. Crystal structures of free and metal-bound IPP isomerase show that the protein requires a divalent cation to fold into its active conformation (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar, 15Bonanno J.B. Edo C. Eswar N. Pieper U. Romanowski M.J. Ilyin V. Gerchman S.E. Kycia H. Studier F.W. Sali A. Burley S.K. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2001; 98: 12896-12901Google Scholar). Three histidines and two glutamates form a distorted octahedral metal coordination site for the divalent cation. In the structure of E. coli IPP isomerase, residues Cys-67 and Glu-116 (corresponding to Cys 139-and Glu-207 in theSaccharomyces cerevisiae enzyme) face each other within the active site and are located close to the metal-binding site. Based on this structure, a mechanism was proposed where the cysteine initiates the reaction by protonating the carbon-carbon double bond and one of the glutamates in the metal coordination sphere (Glu-114 or Glu-116) assists with proton elimination (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar). To gain further insight into the catalytic mechanism of IPP isomerase, we obtained crystal structures of the E. coli protein crystallized in the presence of N,N-dimethyl-2-amino-1-ethyl diphosphate (Scheme FS2, NIPP, 3), a transition state analogue (8Reardon J.E. Abeles R.H. Biochemistry. 1986; 25: 5609-5616Google Scholar, 9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar), and 3,4-epoxy-3-methyl-1-butyl diphosphate (EIPP, 4), a mechanism-based irreversible inhibitor (9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar, 10Poulter C.D. Muelhbacher M. Davis D.R. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989; 111: 3740-3742Google Scholar, 11Lu X.J. Christensen D.J. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1992; 31: 9955-9960Google Scholar). In NIPP, the positively charged ammonium group mimics the putative tertiary carbocation formed by protonation of the double bond in IPP. The inhibitor forms a stable noncovalent complex with IPP isomerase. EIPP is an irreversible inhibitor that forms a covalent bond to Cys-139 in the yeast enzyme. Analysis of the crystal structures (1.96 Å) of complexes between those transition state analogues and wild-typeE. coli IPP isomerase provides evidence for the involvement of Cys-67 and Glu-116 and suggests Tyr-104 may also be part of the catalytic machinery. Recombinant E. coli IPP isomerase (C-terminal His-tagged) was produced and purified as previously described (16Oudjama Y. Durbecq V. Sainz G. Clantin B. Tricot C. Stalon V. Villeret V. Droogmans L. Acta Crystallogr. Sect. D Biol. Crystallogr. 2001; 57: 287-288Google Scholar). Prior to enzymatic activity tests or crystallization trials, the protein was treated by EDTA (5 mm) and dialyzed against metal-free 50 mmTris/HCl (pH 7.4) buffer. The assay of E. coli IPP isomerase is based on the acidic lability of the DMAPP described by Satterwhite (17Satterwhite D.M. Methods Enzymol. 1985; 110: 92-99Google Scholar). The allylic product is hydrolyzed in aqueous acid, whereas IPP is stable. The reaction was initiated by adding the enzyme to the assay mixture constituted of Tris/HCl buffer 50 mm, pH 7.5, and 18 ॖm [1-14C]IPP in a final volume of 50 ॖl. The effect of divalent cations was tested by addition of Mn2+ and/or Mg2+ to the buffer. After incubation at 37 °C, the reaction was stopped by adding 400 ॖl of methanol/concentrated HCl (4:1, v/v). The mixture was subsequently incubated for 10 min at 37 °C, and the radioactive products were extracted with chloroform. The extraction was facilitated by vigorous vortexing followed by centrifuging at 10,000 × g for 2 min. A 200-ॖl portion of the organic layer was mixed with 5 ml of scintillation mixture (ICN Biomedicals). The radioactivity is counted as a measure for the conversion of IPP into DMAPP. Crystals of E. coli IPP isomerase were grown at room temperature by the hanging drop method. Protein (10 mg/ml) was equilibrated against a reservoir containing PEG2000 (167), ammonium sulfate (100 mm), and MnCl2 (10 mm) buffered with Tris/maleate at pH 5.5. Complexes were obtained by soaking crystals of the enzyme with NIPP (3) and EIPP (4). Solutions of the inhibitors (25 mm) in Tris/maleate (100 mm, pH 5.5), PEG2000 (167), ammonium sulfate (100 mm), MnCl2 (10 mm), and glycerol (257) were replaced every 8 h for at least 24 h. After soaking, crystals were flash-frozen, and diffraction data were collected with a Mar345 imaging plate system from marresearch equipped with Osmic optics and running on an FR591 rotating anode generator. Diffraction data were processed with the MarFLM suite. In the presence of metal, the protein crystallizes in the space group P212121 with cell parameters a = 69.3, b = 72.6, and c = 92.5 Å. There are two molecules in the asymmetric unit, related by 2-fold non-crystallographic symmetry. Data sets were recorded at 1.96 Å resolution for the NIPP and EIPP complexes. Refinements were performed with the program Shelxl97 (18Sheldrick G.M. Schneider T.R. Methods Enzymol. 1997; 277: 319-343Google Scholar) using the structure of unliganded IPP isomerase (Protein Data Bank reference code 1hxz) as starting model. Non-crystallographic restraints were used during the whole refinement (NCSY restrain in Shelxl97) except for the conformation of the inhibitor, which was refined independently in the two molecules of the asymmetric unit. As a test, non-crystallographic restraints were removed and further refinement cycles performed. This led to a small drop inR1 but no significant decrease inRfree. Electron density maps were inspected with the graphical program Turbo-Frodo (19Roussel A. Cambillau C. Turbo-Frodo Biographics Architecture et Fonction des Macromolecules Biologique. University of Marseille, France1992Google Scholar). Quality of the models was analyzed with the program Procheck (20Laskowski R.A. McArthur M.W. Thornton J.M. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 1993; 26: 283-291Google Scholar). Final coordinates have been deposited at the Protein Data Bank under codes 1NFS and 1NFZ for the NIPP and EIPP complexes, respectively. Crystal structures were refined at 1.96 Å resolution forE. coli IPP isomerase in complex withN,N-dimethyl-2-amino-1-ethyl diphosphate (SchemeFS2, NIPP,3) and 3,4-epoxy-3-methyl-1-butyl diphosphate (EIPP, 4). The quality of the data and the refinement are summarized in Table I. The protein crystallizes with two molecules in the asymmetric unit related by non-crystallographic symmetry. Both molecules adopt an identical fold, and the geometries of the complexes with NIPP and EIPP are similar.Table IData collection and refinement statisticsNIPPEIPPCrystal data Space groupP212121P212121 Cell dimensions (Å)69.10569.10172.22372.10691.72291.520 Subunits per asymmetric unit22Data set Wavelength (Å)1.541791.54179 Highest resolution (Å)1.971.97 Total reflections107068102886 Unique reflections2778828408 Observed reflections (I> 2ς(I))2330226786 Completeness (7)1-aStatistics for the highest resolution shell (2.08–1.97 Å) are given in parentheses.94.8 (94.8)98.8 (97.2) Rmerge(7)1-aStatistics for the highest resolution shell (2.08–1.97 Å) are given in parentheses.4.2 (24.4)3.7 (10.1) I/ς(I)9.28.8Refinement Resolution range (Å)10–1.9710–1.97 Number of protein atoms28222822 Number of ligand atoms3234 Number of water molecules117298 Rcryst (observed/all data) (7)21.0/22.217.6/18.0 Rfree1-bFree test subset represents 107 of total unique reflections.(7)26.223.7 Root mean square deviationsBond lengths (Å)0.0050.006Bond angles (Å)0.0190.021 Average B-factorAll protein atoms (Å2)35.3826.95All ligand atoms (Å2)41.8036.16All water molecules (Å2)36.9434.31 Ramachadran plot1-cAs defined by PROCHECK, Gly and Pro residues excluded.Most favored regions (7)89.288.2Additionally allowed region (7)10.811.8Generously allowed region (7)0.00.0Disallowed region (7)0.00.01-a Statistics for the highest resolution shell (2.08–1.97 Å) are given in parentheses.1-b Free test subset represents 107 of total unique reflections.1-c As defined by PROCHECK, Gly and Pro residues excluded. Open table in a new tab E. coli IPP isomerase folds into a compact globular protein that belongs to the class of α/ॆ proteins, with an original architecture (Fig. 1). In the presence of divalent metal, the N-terminal residues fold into a small ॆ-sheet domain of two antiparallel strands that partly covers a pocket comprising the putative catalytic site. This domain is not observed in the absence of metal (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar). In the metal-bound, active conformation, the protein forms a unique distorted octahedral metal coordination site composed of residues His-25, His-32, His-69, Glu-114, and Glu-116 (Fig.1). Both carboxylate oxygens of Glu-114 coordinate to the metal. In contrast, only one carboxylate oxygen of Glu-116 coordinates with the metal, and the other oxygen faces the thiol group of Cys-67, which is ∼7 Å away. density in the maps at the and conformation of the transition state analogue NIPP (3) and the irreversible inhibitor EIPP in the structures of the two complexes maps of the refined models the on each inhibitor in the active In the complex of E. with NIPP the inhibitor an conformation with the positively charged ammonium moiety between Glu-116 and Cys-67 angles the conformation of NIPP are given in with with residues of the active for complexes of IPP isomerase with NIPP and EIPP = or divalent metal cations are located in the site of IPP isomerase, one to His-25, His-32, His-69, Glu-114, Glu-116 and the other to Cys-67, and the diphosphate group of the Open table in a new tab a = or b divalent metal cations are located in the site of IPP isomerase, one to His-25, His-32, His-69, Glu-114, Glu-116 and the other to Cys-67, and the diphosphate group of the The is as The two are Cys-67, and the is In this is to be by an the oxygen of Glu-116 that is not with the divalent metal about Table of the divalent metal cation site the carboxylate form of The group of Tyr-104 is of this residue is in IPP in the active to Glu-116, suggests that it be involved in the proton transfer to the that Tyr-104 residue during is not is also in the active site to with the positively charged ammonium moiety in NIPP and the at of IPP or DMAPP during through a J. Protein Sci. Scholar, Scholar). This is the that provides evidence for a in a state analogue A the in may the activity for the mutant (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar). The diphosphate group in NIPP is by a of and A divalent metal with a oxygen of each to form a is to that found in crystal structures of other diphosphate proteins, isoprenoid diphosphate and or that the diphosphate moieties of the or The diphosphate group is further by with and The of those residues has been by site-directed mutagenesis (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar). water molecules have also been located in the active site coli IPP isomerase. Although not involved in the a in of the in the active site of the water molecules were located close to the ammonium moiety in NIPP (corresponding to the positively charged of the putative tertiary carbocationic The water molecules in the active site of IPP isomerase in a of the divalent metal and and the diphosphate moiety of in the absence of inhibitor, the active site of the structure of E. coli IPP isomerase (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar) molecules of and phosphate from the buffer that between and water molecules those that water molecules this site in the absence of other In the complex of E. with density is observed with a covalent bond between the of Cys-67 in the active site and of the inhibitor (Fig. the epoxide in been with of thiol moiety in The formed moiety at forms a with Tyr-104 with a about Å Although the is not it is to that the group in Tyr-104 is based on the between and and as for the group in the covalently This to the that the group in Tyr-104 may its proton Glu-116) to the The conformation of EIPP is to that for the NIPP the diphosphate moiety of EIPP is by with a divalent metal and residues and of NIPP with IPP isomerase showed that NIPP formed a stable complex with the enzyme with a × M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar). The complex was stable in but the inhibitor was upon with and at 37 for h. The indicate that NIPP is a transition intermediate analogue where the positively charged ammonium group mimics a putative tertiary carbocation formed upon protonation of the carbon-carbon double in IPP or DMAPP during catalysis. In contrast, EIPP is an irreversible of the yeast and E. coli The epoxide forms a stable covalent that is stable to and (9Muelherbacher M. Poulter C.D. Biochemistry. 1988; 27: 7315-7328Google Scholar). The crystal structures of E. coli IPP isomerase with NIPP and EIPP support a mechanism for in which the step is the protonation of the carbon-carbon double bond in IPP or DMAPP. The of NIPP in the complex that Glu-116 is to with (Fig. NIPP is in by an with is by a with the of A is for the tertiary carbocationic formed during the isomerization. The of the protonating has not been Glu-116 is an essential active-site is to the divalent metal, which the carboxylate form of the acid. in the absence of Glu-116 is given the of Glu-116 in the coordination sphere of the metal. the structure of the complex with NIPP suggests that protonation of involves Glu-116 and that the carboxylate moiety the carbocationic water molecules that as proton during are observed Tyr-104 is to the carboxylate in Glu-116, both in the unliganded structure of IPP isomerase (14Durbecq V. Sainz G. Oudjama Y. Clantin B. Bompard-Gilles C. Tricot C. Caillet J. Stalon V. Droogmans L. Villeret V. EMBO J. 2001; 20: 1530-1537Google Scholar) and in the NIPP The group in Tyr-104 be the of the proton to the double bond in In the presence of Cys-67 as a that the epoxide and forms a covalent bond to (Fig. the of the reaction involves protonation of the in to the protonation of the double bond in IPP during followed by of the by the thiol group in Although not deprotonation of the thiol to the the it is that Cys-67 as a to removal of the proton from carbocationic intermediate during the isomerization. The interconversion of IPP and DMAPP proceeds by an antarafacial protonation/deprotonation of the The structures of NIPP and EIPP complexes with IPP isomerase that the active site of the enzyme has an acid on one of the moiety of the and a on the IPP and DMAPP to to the active site in conformation to for the antarafacial stereochemistry of the reaction is not The residues that and protons in of IPP Tyr-104 and Cys-67, as an mixture of and be of for of DMAPP the form of Cys-67 be the proton to DMAPP, and Tyr-104 be the proton In both reactions Glu-116 as the essential acid not proton that the of the of the of Cys-67 or Tyr-104 in the enzyme of be as proton and Although the deprotonation step is and incubation of IPP and DMAPP in in exchange of of the on to in the tertiary intermediate (7Street I.P. Christensen D.J. Poulter C.D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990; 112: 8577-8578Google Scholar). A mechanism for of IPP to DMAPP, which is with the of the complexes of E. coli IPP isomerase with NIPP and is presented in These are summarized as 1. The diphosphate moiety of the ligand is by a of and that involves a divalent metal and residues and The reaction is initiated by protonation of the double bond with involvement of The proton be given by this residue or from Tyr-104 located within of the carboxylate group of The that the proton from water be but an water has not been The tertiary carbocationic intermediate is by the carboxylate form of Glu-116 and by a with the of The thiol moiety of Cys-67, in the assists in the proton from the tertiary cation. the thiol proton Cys-67 be to
17