1992 · 55 citations · 7 references
ArtsComputer SciencePsychologyHuman Factors PsychologyHuman-computer InteractionUser Experience DesignHeuristic EvaluationInterface DesignMethod ComparisonUsability EngineeringUsability EvaluationUsability TestingHeuristic Evaluation MethodologyHuman Factors TestingLaboratory Performance AssessmentLaboratory TestingLaboratory Usability TestingNielsen's HeuristicsUsability Problems IdentificationUse Of Experts
Traditional laboratory usability testing is frequently not performed due to a company's lack of funds, planning, or human factors expertise. Consequently, there is increasing interest in finding alternative usability testing methods that are easier and cheaper to implement than traditional laboratory usability testing. Recent studies are beginning to study and compare such techniques. These methods include Heuristic Evaluation (Nielsen and Molich, 1990), and Cognitive Walkthrough (Polson, Lewis, Rieman, & Wharton, 1990). For Heuristic Evaluation, Nielsen (1991) found that human-factors Experts were the best at finding an interface's usability problems, especially Experts who were also expert in the interface domain. Desurvire, Lawrence, & Atwood (1991) found Experts' evaluations were the most reliable, and their best guess predictions were predictive of laboratory performance. Karat, Campbell, & Fiegel (1992) similarly found that heuristic results were reliable and significantly predictive of laboratory data, yet empirical laboratory testing identified four and five times as many problems. Jeffries, Miller, Wharton, and Uyeda (1991) found that via Heuristic Evaluation, more severe problems were found than with laboratory testing or the Cognitive Walkthrough. This comparison study did, however, only utilize Experts in the heuristic condition, and System Designers in the Cognitive Walkthrough.
7
Heuristic evaluation of user interfaces
Jakob Nielsen, Rolf Molich · 1990 · 3.4K citations
Finding usability problems through heuristic evaluation
Jakob Nielsen · 1992 · 1.1K citations
User interface evaluation in the real world
Robin Jeffries, James R. Miller, Cathleen Wharton et al. · 1991 · 620 citations
Testing a walkthrough methodology for theory-based design of walk-up-and-use interfaces
Clayton Lewis, Peter G. Polson, Cathleen Wharton et al. · 1990 · 561 citations
Arts, Computer Science, Design +12