Spatial Neglect: A Clinical Handbook for Diagnosis and Treatment.

Irwin B. Suchoff

Optometry and Vision Science · 2000 · 127 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Spatial Neglect: A Clinical Handbook for Diagnosis and Treatment. Ian H. Robertson, Peter W. Halligan. Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis. 1999. Pages: 192. Price: $34.95. ISBN 0-86377-809-7 FIGUREFigureArguably, neglect is one of the most fascinating and challenging entities encountered by clinicians who provide care for patients with acquired brain injury. It is difficult to diagnose because, most frequently, it seems to be there at certain times and in certain circumstances, but not others. When undetected, there can be serious implications for the patient’s rehabilitation program as well as the ability to perform activities of daily living. Nevertheless, as the authors of this text point out, it received little attention until the 1970s. The prevailing attitude was that these patients’ inability to attend or respond to objects or people in a particular portion of space (virtually always the left) was the product of a primary sensory or motor defect subsequent to the brain injury. Research, particularly during the last 25 years, has revealed that in the case of vision, for example, neglect is “something more” than a sensory loss as determined by perimetric means. The clinical enigma that surfaces in these instances is that some patients who manifest neglect behaviors, such as continually bumping into or tripping on objects on the left, will show an homonymous hemianopic loss by kinetic or static testing, whereas others will not. Some neglect patients have visual field defects, some do not. There is now a voluminous literature on neglect. Much of it has sought to specify the “something more” alluded to above. As this literature has grown, so has the number of names to describe this mysterious phenomenon. The particular names are indicative of the author’s particular bias in explaining it: thus, “hemi-spatial imperception,” and “unilateral visual inattention” are but two examples. The clinician who seeks to treat these patients can be overwhelmed by the different explanations and often left with only bits of information to conduct enlightened diagnosis and management of neglect. Robertson and Halligan have produced a text that, as the title indicates, is targeted at clinicians. Yet this is not merely a cookbook on how to diagnose and provide treatment for neglect. Their coverage of the research and models of neglect that have evolved is surprisingly complete in so concise a work. The first chapter thoroughly discusses the clinical presentation of neglect. It introduces the reader to the concept of a neglect syndrome, and elaborates on each type of component behavior. While the main thrust in this chapter is vision, the point that neglect can also occur in the other senses is made. Thus, auditory, kinesthetic, and motor (proprioceptive) neglect are also covered with a number of clinical examples. Additionally, some cognitive aspects are presented, such as neglect of mental images and neglect dysgraphia and dyslexia. The authors also report that neglect can occur in personal and/or peripersonal and/or extrapersonal space. They make the clinically important point that most tests of neglect are conducted in peripersonal (i.e., within arm’s reach) space. This explains why some patients will be judged not to have neglect when tested in peripersonal space but are unresponsive to objects at a distance, or vice versa. The second chapter, “Clinical issues for the diagnosis and interpretation of neglect,” makes clear that both a primary sensory or motor dysfunction, and an attentional or perceptual deficit must be considered in the understanding of and subsequent testing for neglect in all modalities. For example, the clinical challenge in patients with proprioceptive neglect is to determine whether the inability to move a limb on command is a product of a motor defect, motor neglect, or both. These first two chapters are rich in terms of interpreting research findings, and providing clearly written and pertinent clinical examples so that the reader is appreciative of the complexities of neglect. Having educated the reader in the phenomenological aspects, chapter 3 lists and describes the various tests for visual neglect. There is a thorough discussion of the numerous paper and pencil tests such as cancellation, copying of figures and line bisection tests. The various subtests and the scoring and interpretation of the Behavioral Inattention Test (BIT) are well covered. Surprisingly, some of the computerized tests for neglect are not included in this chapter, but in the next. Nevertheless, this chapter provides the means for clinicians to use appropriate probes. Chapter 4 is an exposition of further assessments of neglect and related disorders. Measures to determine the degree of personal neglect (i.e., shaving or combing one’s hair on one side only) are discussed, along with anosognosia. This condition is one of the components of the neglect syndrome and connotes the individual’s unawareness or denial of his/her performance deficits. The phenomena of extinction and neglect dyslexia are also covered. The final two chapters explore the prognosis and treatment of neglect. In chapter 5, the point is made that in the case of stroke, clinical observations show that severe effects tend to lessen within the first 6 months, but that there is little meaningful research in this domain. However, the authors contend that in many instances in which the severe effects of neglect subside, there remain at least residual effects. They go on to discuss the most used technique for remediation, training to scan into the affected field, and are of the opinion that the research is not conclusive, and that there is usually little generalization from the training situation to other tasks. The final chapter lists other attempts to ameliorate neglect. These include limb activation training, auditory feedback, training of sustained attention and awareness, caloric stimulation of the ear, mechanical stimulation of the neck muscles, monocular eye patching and medication. The last example is the use of half-field Fresnel prisms. Those optometrists who are seriously involved in the diagnosis and management of patients who have experienced stroke or incurred traumatic brain injury will find this book allows them to more fully understand neglect and acts as a clinical guide to advanced testing and training. Primary care practitioners will find the first two chapters particularly useful to alert them to neglect and enable them to be knowledgeable about treatment options. This can be quite important because of the incidence of stroke in our increasingly aging population. Those who teach courses in visual field testing and diagnosis can also gain by more fully discussing neglect and considering it as a possible source of confusion when interpreting testing that is so frequently oriented toward glaucoma.