Direct Payments and Social Work Practice: The Significance of 'Street-Level Bureaucracy' in Determining Eligibility

Kathryn A. Ellis

The British Journal of Social Work · 2007 · 145 citations · 14 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Cash‑for‑care schemes, promoted by governments seeking fiscal restraint and user movements demanding choice, are replacing direct services in mature welfare states, and recent UK legislation has spurred research interest while revealing tensions and uncertainty among frontline social workers. The study aims to understand how social workers allocate direct payments by applying Lipsky’s street‑level bureaucracy theory. The authors examined assessment and care‑management practices within a single English council to analyze how workers apply the theory. The study concludes that Lipsky’s theory remains a valuable lens for analyzing frontline behavior around direct payments, even after a decade of managerialism.

Abstract

Sponsored both by governments intent upon fiscal restraint and user movements keen to extend choice and control, 'cash-for-care' schemes are replacing direct services across mature welfare states. Recent legislation on direct payments, which has enacted the UK version of cash-for-care, has attracted considerable research interest in the UK. Previous studies point to a number of tensions for social workers in the implementation process which give rise, in turn, to considerable uncertainty, even hostility, on the part of front line staff. This article, which discusses the findings of a study of assessment and care management practice in one English council, seeks to make sense of social workers' approach to the allocation of direct payments by reference to Lipsky's (1980) theory of 'street-level bureaucracy'. The author concludes that despite ten years of managerialism, in the course of which professional practice has been routinized and regulated, Lipsky's work is still useful in analysing front line behaviour around direct payments.

References

14