A timed test of swallowing capacity for neurological patients.

Kalyanee M. Nathadwarawala, J. Nicklin, C M Wiles

Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery & Psychiatry · 1992 · 229 citations · 8 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

A timed test of swallowing capacity has been developed for patients with neurogenic dysphagia. Swallowing speed <10 ml/s was validated against patient complaints in 81 neurological patients. Swallowing speed proved highly reliable, largely independent of flavor or temperature, with normal values that vary by sex and age; it showed 96 % sensitivity and 69 % specificity for detecting dysphagia, with some false positives in multiple sclerosis, and was found to correlate with clinical complaints, confirming its validity as a useful index for assessing and monitoring neurological dysphagia.

Abstract

A timed test of swallowing capacity has been designed for use in patients with neurogenic dysphagia. Swallowing speed (ml/s) has been demonstrated to have high intra- and inter- rater and test- retest reliability, and to be essentially independent of flavour or temperature. "Guideline" normal values were established in individuals without a swallowing disorder: swallowing speed was less in females than males and declined in both groups with age. The validity of a swallowing speed less than 10 ml/s as an index of abnormal swallowing was tested by comparison with the complaint of abnormal swallowing in a group of 81 neurological patients. Swallowing speed had a sensitivity of 96% and specificity of 69%: some apparent false positive responses were found in patients with disordered swallowing, mainly due to multiple sclerosis. Using a standard questionnaire and examination a similar pattern of symptoms and signs were statistically associated with both the clinical complaint of abnormal swallowing and swallowing speed. It is concluded that swallowing speed is a reliable and valid index for assessing disordered swallowing in neurological patients and may be of value in monitoring response to therapy.

References

8