The Effects of Public Investment on Private Investment in Developing Economies

Lütfi Erden, Randall G. Holcombe

Public Finance Review · 2005 · 178 citations · 30 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Literature on public investment in developing economies yields inconsistent evidence on whether it complements or crowds out private investment. The study applies pooled specifications of a standard investment model to panels of developing (1980‑1997) and developed economies to examine the relationship between public and private investment. In developing economies, public investment complements private investment (10 % public → 2 % private) but is constrained by bank credit, whereas in developed economies it crowds out private investment and is driven by different factors.

Abstract

The literature on the impact of public investment in developing economies gives inconsistent results on whether it complements or crowds out private investment. Applying several pooled specifications of a standard investment model to a panel of developing economies for 1980 to 1997, this study finds that public investment complements private investment, and that, on average, a 10 percent increase in public investment is associated with a 2 percent increase in private investment. The results also indicate that private investment is constrained by the availability of bank credit in developing economies. The same empirical models are run on a panel of developed economies. In contrast to developing economies, public investment crowds out private investment in developed economies. The results show that in a number of important ways, private investment in developed economies is influenced by different factors than private investment in developing economies.

References

30