The emotional meaning of instrumental social support.

Norbert K. Semmer, Achim Elfering, Nicola Jacobshagen, Tanja Perrot, Terry A. Beehr, Norbert Boos

International Journal of Stress Management · 2008 · 295 citations · 31 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Social support is commonly categorized as emotional (e.g., caring, esteem) or instrumental (e.g., informational, tangible). The study tested whether instrumental support is perceived as helpful because it conveys emotional meaning such as caring, understanding, and esteem by surveying 67 hospital patients about supportive situations. Supportive behaviors and their attributed meanings were coded for instrumental versus emotional quality. Instrumental behaviors were often interpreted as emotionally meaningful, especially in private interactions with family and friends, while medical professionals’ instrumental support remained largely instrumental, highlighting the need to convey care and esteem when providing instrumental help.

Abstract

Functional social support can be described as emotional (i.e., caring, esteem, etc.) or instrumental (i.e., informational, tangible) support. Hypothesizing that instrumental support often is interpreted as helpful because of its emotional meaning (signalling caring, understanding, esteem), we asked hospital patients (N = 67) to describe situations (N = 109) during which they were supported, and to indicate why this support was helpful. Both the description of the supportive behaviors and the meaning attributed to them were coded with regard to their instrumental versus emotional quality. As expected, many situations that were instrumental in descriptive terms were emotional in terms of meaning; the reverse occurred very seldom. This effect was confined to private interactions (i.e. interactions involving family and friends), whereas instrumental behaviors of medical professionals were largely instrumental in meaning as well. Results underscore the importance of giving instrumental support in a way that communicates care and esteem.

References

31