Ethnography Versus Case Study ‐ Positioning Research and Researchers

Julie White, Sarah Drew, Trevor Hay

Qualitative Research Journal · 2009 · 63 citations · 11 references

Concepts

TL;DR

This paper describes work on the Australian Research Council–funded “Keeping Connected: Young People, Identity and Schooling” project, which examines the social connection and schooling of young people with long‑term chronic illness. The study aims to explore how young people with chronic illness experience social connection and schooling, and to evaluate whether framing the research as case studies or ethnography better captures these experiences, including considerations of data collection, analysis, and truth claims. The authors employ a mixed‑methods design, with a qualitative component dominating the research effort, to compare case‑study and ethnographic approaches through varied data‑collection and analysis strategies.

Abstract

In this paper we narrate a story of working on a large project funded by an Australian Research Council Linkage grant the ‘Keeping Connected: Young People, Identity and Schooling’ project. The purpose of the study is to consider the social connection and schooling of young people who have experienced long‐term chronic illness. While the research involves both quantitative and qualitative elements, the qualitative component is the largest and involves the most researcher time and diversity. At an early stage of the project, three of the researchers working on the qualitative team consider why the study was framed as a series of case studies rather than as ethnography. The second issue considered in this paper is the different approaches to data collection, data analysis and truth claims we might take.

References

11