Converse Relationship Between In Vitro Osteogenic Differentiation and In Vivo Bone Healing Elicited by Different Populations of Muscle-Derived Cells Genetically Engineered to Express BMP4

Abstract

In all animals (nine rats per group), transduced PP1 cells expressing BMP4 demonstrated significantly advanced healing compared with PP6 cells expressing BMP4 and control cells expressing LacZ. We found that constitutive BMP4 expression negatively impacted the in vitro proliferation and in vivo survival rates of PP6 cells, but not PP1 cells. BMP4 exposure also directly inhibited the proliferation and induced the apoptosis of PP6 cells, but not PP1 cells. The impairment in PP6 cell proliferation was directly associated with the osteogenic differentiation of these cells. These results indicate that PP1 cells are better suited than osteoprogenitor cells for use as cellular vehicles to deliver osteogenic BMP4 to improve bone healing and that cellular behavior in response to a particular gene can be used to predict the cells' performance as delivery vehicles in ex vivo gene therapy.